On BNET: Turn your iPhone into an air mouse
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet
TalkBack 6 of 62:
Next »
« Previous
That's not true
It doesn't have to be an "exact" copy to violate the copyright. Copyright law extends to "derivative works" as well. A "derivative work" is "an expressive creation that includes major, basic copyrighted aspects of an original, previously created first work."

I think it is pretty obvious that Scrabulous is a "derivative work" of Scrabble, and therefore Hasbro is 100% in the right on this issue. Apparently Facebook sees this too, as they have pulled Scrabulous off of their system.
Posted by: JamesAHall   Posted on: 07/29/08 You are currently: a Guest | Members login | Terms of Use
Reply to Story Reply to Message

Alert moderator to an offensive message

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

WHAT???  Henaway | 07/25/08
Why waste money when it was just a nuisance??  wackoae | 07/25/08
Not an exact copy at all  ZDNET_guest666 | 07/25/08
Not a copy? Are you nuts?  JamesAHall | 07/25/08
Of course it's a knock-off, but it's not an exact copy  ZDNET_guest666 | 07/25/08
That's not true  JamesAHall | 07/29/08
Copyright law doesn't apply to ideas  ZDNET_guest666 | 07/29/08
Nope  dcmtr | 07/31/08
Scrabble has been around...  AtomicFusion | 07/25/08
Copyrights Are Renewable  Mark.Eichman | 07/26/08
That's not true  ZDNET_guest666 | 07/29/08
What the US Copyright Office Says  jlafitte | 08/07/08
No..  Etch44 | 08/07/08
Copyright doesn't apply - Hasbro has no case, bro  ZDNET_guest666 | 07/25/08
Copyright  kohathi | 07/25/08
14 years with optional 14-year renewal...  ZDNET_guest666 | 07/25/08
renewal is a wonderful thing  Socoling | 07/25/08
Read up on copyright history  ZDNET_guest666 | 07/29/08
assignation....  Socoling | 07/25/08
RE: Scrabble-Scrabulous standoff spells L-A-W-S-U-I-T  qwerty690 | 07/25/08
You can't copyright ideas.  ZDNET_guest666 | 07/25/08
A set of rules for a game is more than an idea once it gets published.  jk0726 | 07/26/08
No. Copyright covers wording, not ideas  ZDNET_guest666 | 07/29/08
confusing copyright, patent, and trademark  josephmartins | 08/07/08
Nope  fadzlan@... | 07/30/08
ah but lotus 123 was not the original spreadsheet  mombo | 08/07/08
Lotus 123???  The Smoking Man | 08/07/08
You're thinking of VisiCalc....  jlafitte | 08/07/08
two bites of the apple...  jlafitte | 08/07/08
RE: Scrabble-Scrabulous standoff spells L-A-W-S-U-I-T  Terrygirl | 07/25/08
the bottom line is.....  djd221 | 07/25/08
RE: Scrabble-Scrabulous standoff spells L-A-W-S-U-I-T  bill4935 | 07/25/08
And Yet...  Mark.Eichman | 07/26/08
Copyright needs to be protected by the owner  mombo | 08/07/08
Patent the Alphabet  ashworth102680 | 07/25/08
the alphabet was public domain  mombo | 08/07/08
So are words ...  The Smoking Man | 08/07/08
Next, the little geniuses can "invent" these Facebook games  Tech99_z | 07/25/08
Presentation on Copyright - Lawrence Lessig  jkantony | 07/26/08
Re: Presentation on Copyright - Lawrence Lessig  hitech_rednek | 08/07/08
70 years is too long  ZDNET_guest666 | 07/26/08
Agreed 100%  ZDNET_guest666 | 07/29/08
Disney ...  The Smoking Man | 08/07/08
RE: Scrabble-Scrabulous standoff spells L-A-W-S-U-I-T  saxmanb | 07/26/08
Why are performances "copyrighted"?  kohathi | 07/27/08
RE: Scrabble-Scrabulous standoff spells L-A-W-S-U-I-T  saxmanb | 07/27/08
RE: Scrabble-Scrabulous standoff spells L-A-W-S-U-I-T  Panda129 | 07/29/08
I agree, Hasbro has no case  rahullak@... | 07/29/08
that's where trademark comes in  merc2dogs` | 08/08/08
Not Copyright, but maybe Trademark breach  dhruva15 | 07/30/08
RE: Scrabble-Scrabulous standoff spells L-A-W-S-U-I-T  CBR1000F | 08/01/08
Just plain thievery  verelse | 08/04/08
Don't be Dumb  ericvorheese | 08/04/08
Don't be Dumber...  pmcm | 08/07/08
On Copyright and the Other Thing  tzenes | 08/04/08
Screw the customer  wystan1000 | 08/05/08
Evil Giant Coporate Copyrights  Draven35 | 08/07/08
Typically Insane Case  madrucke@... | 08/07/08
... and the winner will be ...  oldbaritone | 08/07/08
RE: Scrabble-Scrabulous standoff spells L-A-W-S-U-I-T  SphinxRising58 | 08/07/08
Well Said.  Dauplat | 08/07/08
RE: Scrabble-Scrabulous standoff spells L-A-W-S-U-I-T  The Smoking Man | 08/07/08

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement
advertisement
  • Smart Tech Expert advice on innovations in healthcare and the green technologies that make it happen. Find out more
  • Smart Business Discussion and advice on management issues that revolve around making your world smarter and more useful. More Smart Advice
  • Smart People The best and worst moves in the management and strategy trenches. Learn More