On CBS MoneyWatch: Best Colleges You've Never Heard Of
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet
TalkBack 40 of 67:
Next »
« Previous
Oh, I hope you're kidding...
... but the knot in my stomach suggests that you're not. So...

the whole point of living in a capitalist society is our ability to make a buck.

Sure, why not-- imprecise, but I'll live with it, so long as we emphasize the word "ability". That's not the same as "obligation".

...taking something that someone else developed\invented and creating a product that you make money from is stealing

That's pretty ambiguous. Sure, if I steal your car and use it to run my business, you've got a point. If I see someone else using a car and decide that's nifty, the matter is considerably less clear.

In the end, what you're really doing is taking advantage of other people's work because you are too greedy and lazy to come up with anything original on your own.

No, that's not it at all. People contribute to Open Source. They don't go out and take. They create and give.

The patent violations...

What violations? It seems that you're assuming a lot. Did you just read the headline and assume that the article had substance. Tsk, tsk... you should know better than that.

...a complete lack of creativity and talent of the part of the open source community.

We await your justification for such a statement. Please, be specific.
Posted by: Martin Marvinski   Posted on: 08/06/04 You are currently: a Guest | Members login | Terms of Use
Reply to Story Reply to Message

Alert moderator to an offensive message

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

The Sky Is Falling! The Sky Is Falling! Ahhhh!  P. Douglas | 08/05/04
Well what the hey!  Jay Cash | 08/05/04
hahahaha  ejourner | 08/05/04
The green party, Munich Linux Patents  Nigel Johnstone | 08/05/04
EP0689133 (Adobe tabbed pallettes) 27-Dec-95  Nigel Johnstone | 08/05/04
tab patent invalid  Joe Blow_z | 08/05/04
Borland's Delphi had tabs too.  enduser_z | 08/06/04
EP335638 System for coordination activities of plurality of actors (1989)  Nigel Johnstone | 08/05/04
EP501416 Document data processing method for document retrieval  Nigel Johnstone | 08/05/04
EP0807891 Stateless Shopping Carts, Sun 1997  Nigel Johnstone | 08/05/04
EP0927945 Amazon taking the 'p'  Nigel Johnstone | 08/05/04
FUD for FUD?  OhMyGosh | 08/05/04
Microsoft offers true indemnification  Mike Cox | 08/05/04
Of whom?  IT_User | 08/05/04
Users included  Anton Philidor | 08/06/04
Microsoft Offers Almost Useless Indemnification  David Mohring | 08/05/04
denial  ejourner | 08/05/04
nonsense  alstew | 08/16/04
every time i power on  ejourner | 08/05/04
9/10  Tran McNally | 08/06/04
Alarmist headlines  IT_User | 08/05/04
Alarmist conclusions  Anton Philidor | 08/06/04
Patent system SHOULD be falling  seosamh_z | 08/05/04
Yep  IT_User | 08/05/04
I read yours  seosamh_z | 08/05/04
Don't worry--IBM, Novell, Red Hat, etc. will see to it that it will  Jeff Spicoli | 08/05/04
Linux isn't the issue, Jeff  IT_User | 08/05/04
In the mean time...  hipparchus2000 | 08/05/04
Don't Worry  alstew | 08/16/04
I Agree  P. Douglas | 08/05/04
This can be applied to more than just Linux  Chad_z | 08/05/04
Yes, all of open source is at risk  Anton Philidor | 08/06/04
Already started  seosamh_z | 08/07/04
Not just open source  voska | 08/09/04
Linux plagues patents  Yen_z | 08/05/04
Open Source Is An Affront To Capitalism  chrislovesdana | 08/05/04
Monopolies are a greater Affront To Capitalism  David Mohring | 08/05/04
YES, YES a brain resides here  ejourner | 08/05/04
What sort of computer did you use to write your post?  Jay Cash | 08/05/04
Oh, I hope you're kidding...  Martin Marvinski | 08/06/04
If you believe that about Open Source and Capitalism, you will love this:  B.O.F.H. | 08/06/04
Open Source is Capitolism at it's best.  voska | 08/09/04
Excessive capitalism is an affront to democracy  techboy_z | 08/11/04
Patent system plunders Microsoft, threatens customers  David Mohring | 08/05/04
yup  ejourner | 08/05/04
microsoft, just leave  ejourner | 08/05/04
Funny, your hero says the same thing.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 08/06/04
but the free software communityhas been amassing patents too  hipparchus2000 | 08/05/04
And then gave everything away with the GPL.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 08/06/04
Try reading the GPL  voska | 08/09/04
Would like to know source of financing  donpar@... | 08/05/04
Easy, it's the Public Patent Foundation.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 08/06/04
Time to re-read your EULAs.  Seething Ganglia | 08/06/04
Guess all that freedom is all that free  FilledOut | 08/06/04
Proprietary protection ???  Update victim | 08/06/04
Sorry, you are wrong.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 08/06/04
Subject too does not mean you are the target  voska | 08/09/04
Where I disagree completely.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 08/06/04
Which is your right  seosamh_z | 08/06/04
The GPL has been tested in one court already  B.O.F.H. | 08/06/04
Completely different context.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 08/07/04
You want to invalidate end user/developer licences?  B.O.F.H. | 08/07/04
GPL is based upon US Copyright law  B.O.F.H. | 08/07/04
You missed the point of unique  voska | 08/09/04
You're kidding, right?  Robert Crocker | 08/10/04
Europe cures the plague  ehj | 08/09/04
Thanks God  alstew | 08/16/04

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement
advertisement

SmartPlanet

Click Here