On The Insider: Britney's Bikini-Clad Top 10
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet
TalkBack 29 of 93:
Next »
« Previous
You're still missing the point
You still think of property as a physical asset. If you OWN a certain spectrum, and someone is broadcasting on it, you are infringed. Their physical location does not matter in the least.

In BOTH cases (land and spectrum) verifiable infringement happens. You don't need a special agency to police infringement in either case.

The FCC has places a limit on Ham radio operators to prevent just such abuses (the most common legal example).

And turning spectrum into private (and tradeable) property would have the same effect. Just as you could evict squatters, you could shut down those who broadcast on your spectrum illegally, whether they do it from their own land or from outer space.

Without the FCC anyone could set up a commercial multimillion watt transmitter on the cheapest location they could find, maximize their profits without due regard to your/our safety.

If you owned spectrum, then you could go to the police and say "see, they are broadcasting on my wavelength," and the police would shut them down. It would be then up to the infringer to prove their case in court.
Posted by: John Carroll   Posted on: 06/09/04 You are currently: a Guest | Members login | Terms of Use
Reply to Story Reply to Message

Alert moderator to an offensive message

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

Yes, if...  FirstNLastN | 06/07/04
(NT) Wow, that was more or less impossible to understand...  James T. Kirk | 06/07/04
phwew....  JoeMama_z | 06/07/04
Don't think you understood the theory...  DarbyOhara | 06/07/04
Wrong solution  daver_z | 06/07/04
...Wrong for Whom?  Dave E._z | 06/09/04
Almost right...  strawbrn | 06/10/04
First Amendment  Font | 06/10/04
Estonia?  dhopp@... | 06/07/04
Re: Estonia  John Carroll ZDNet Moderator | 06/08/04
What a Foolish thought  cygnet@... | 06/07/04
Um,  Patrick Jones | 06/07/04
Station managers aren't Gods, neither should we let them pretend they are  daver_z | 06/07/04
I don't have a subject  Patrick Jones | 06/08/04
Hmmm...  Dave E._z | 06/09/04
Apply this elsewhere  Font | 06/10/04
Abolish Traffic Citations  voiceofreason_z | 06/07/04
Insurance  SC-man | 06/08/04
Public Safety  Font | 06/10/04
Abolish the IRS & UN while you're at it!  kd5auq | 06/07/04
yes, let's!  eLurker | 06/07/04
Yes do abolish the IRS  Linux User 147560 | 06/07/04
Yes do abolish the IRS  SC-man | 06/08/04
if you want the free life  V Sanders | 06/08/04
What are you talking about?  John Carroll ZDNet Moderator | 06/08/04
Abolishing "inconvenient" regulations...  kd5auq | 06/08/04
Straw men 2  John Carroll ZDNet Moderator | 06/09/04
Your neighbor can be on HIS property...  kd5auq | 06/09/04
You're still missing the point  John Carroll ZDNet Moderator | 06/09/04
I think you're missing the point  Middle of the Road | 06/10/04
Nonsense............  Dave E._z | 06/09/04
Nonsense  Middle of the Road | 06/10/04
How Would This Be Different With A Bureaucracy In Charge of Arbitration?  Dave E._z | 06/11/04
Oh Yeah  rcaryl | 06/10/04
True Free markets never work  xshakes | 06/07/04
Define, don't abolish.  Anton Philidor | 06/07/04
I disagree  John Carroll ZDNet Moderator | 06/08/04
Advocate needed  Anton Philidor | 06/08/04
You forget the premis, citizen's own the air ways.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/07/04
wow I agree with you!  nograin | 06/07/04
Re: Citizens  John Carroll ZDNet Moderator | 06/08/04
Yes, no and sort of...  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/08/04
However,  Patrick Jones | 06/08/04
Ham Operator  Middle of the Road | 06/10/04
Re:  John Carroll ZDNet Moderator | 06/09/04
John, John, John,  kd5auq | 06/09/04
Property Rights  John Carroll ZDNet Moderator | 06/09/04
I don't accept the concept of ownership...  kd5auq | 06/09/04
Re: Citizens  John L. Ries | 06/11/04
Land Use  TrustMe_z | 06/11/04
citizens own the airways  elfmaid | 06/10/04
Public Ownership Myth  richardpor | 06/13/04
True Free Markets Alway Work  Raidient | 06/07/04
I can't tell!  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/07/04
What characterizes the wealthiest nations?  John Carroll ZDNet Moderator | 06/08/04
Gut check  Yagotta B. Kidding | 06/08/04
Straw men  John Carroll ZDNet Moderator | 06/09/04
Checks OK  Dave E._z | 06/09/04
In a "True free market" we'd still have...  kd5auq | 06/07/04
True free market work great  voska | 06/07/04
Slavery is the Conservative Answer  cygnet@... | 06/07/04
Only when...  Tim Patterson | 06/07/04
The FCC does not make the Rules  cygnet@... | 06/07/04
"anarchy" in a "free" market?  kd5auq | 06/07/04
"anarchy" in a "free" market  Middle of the Road | 06/10/04
fcc does not make the rules  elfmaid | 06/10/04
Let us internet folks battle it out  Middle of the Road | 06/10/04
FCC Does Not Make the Rules  Middle of the Road | 06/10/04
Dumb Idea  middle of nowhere | 06/07/04
Many things..  Patrick Jones | 06/08/04
Lets just Abolish all Governments  cygnet@... | 06/07/04
Admit it... you just want more skin on Public TV  daver_z | 06/07/04
I do  Patrick Jones | 06/08/04
the world would be a  V Sanders | 06/08/04
Spectrum is not like Land  A.Sinic | 06/08/04
Time To Go ?  ParadigmOdyssey | 06/08/04
Astounding  John Carroll ZDNet Moderator | 06/08/04
not Astounding just your blindness about human nature  xshakes | 06/08/04
Amen! [NT]  WhoIsDaMan | 06/08/04
Translated  John Carroll ZDNet Moderator | 06/09/04
People are stupid  Middle of the Road | 06/10/04
Another Amen  Middle of the Road | 06/10/04
ASTOUNDING  elfmaid | 06/10/04
Not at all  John L. Ries | 06/11/04
Spectrum (unlike land) has no physical boundries...  kd5auq | 06/09/04
Abolish the FCC  larry.lord@... | 06/10/04
the FCC is the big brother we were warned about....  elfmaid | 06/10/04
No can do  Middle of the Road | 06/10/04
Kill the FCC? Don't think so!  whulse | 06/10/04
Yep...  John L. Ries | 06/11/04
I Agree with author  larry1_z | 06/12/04
Amateur, Police, Fire and Aircraft Radio Use  Freon | 06/12/04
Nice thought but it doesn't do anything  trogers_z | 06/13/04

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement
advertisement