This might help, but patents will still stifle inovation.
DonnieBoy | 11/28/06
|

Hear Hear !
htotten | 11/28/06
|

Don't you mean will stifle COPYING.
No_Ax_to_Grind | 11/28/06
|
 
Copyright, Copying...
BanjoPaterson | 11/29/06
|

Intellectual property? An obscure idea in it self.
holst.g@... | 11/29/06
|

Print authors beg
Too Old For IT | 11/29/06
|

On the contrary ...
mwagner@... | 12/01/06
|
So will this effect McDonalds
RIAAsucks | 11/28/06
|

Get Your Facts Straight
Tiquor | 11/28/06
|
 
I'm not sure that helps...
John L. Ries | 11/28/06
|
 
That's the same thing
voska | 11/28/06
|
  
Talk about obviousness
reddtigger | 11/28/06
|
  
I agree
clockmendergb@... | 11/28/06
|
   
NTP to patent the sandwhich
Too Old For IT | 11/29/06
|
  
No it isn't.
osreinstall | 11/28/06
|
   
So, if I make a sandwich the same way....
smoring | 11/29/06
|
    
Still don't get it.
osreinstall | 11/29/06
|
     
Yeah right
voska | 11/29/06
|
     
Never that desperate
osreinstall | 11/29/06
|
     
Here's how I see it
voska | 11/29/06
|
     
And this is how I see it.
osreinstall | 11/29/06
|
     
Reinstall. Why do you do this?
Logics | 11/29/06
|
     
Because I want to.
osreinstall | 11/30/06
|
   
Wrong focus
voska | 11/29/06
|
    
You really don't understand patents.
osreinstall | 11/29/06
|
     
Poor reading skills manybe?
voska | 11/29/06
|
     
Poor spelling skills
osreinstall | 11/29/06
|
     
You should learn to read posts before posting.
Logics | 11/29/06
|
     
You should think before posting.
osreinstall | 11/30/06
|
Trade Secrets; Copyright; NDA; Non Compete
mighetto | 11/28/06
|

Non Compete and other items
jjmcdonald7911@... | 11/29/06
|
 
Funny but...
Logics | 11/29/06
|

The Supremes
Too Old For IT | 11/29/06
|
This is obvious
jsjag1 | 11/28/06
|

Excellent idea
frgough | 11/28/06
|
 
Doesn't work.
Anton Philidor | 11/28/06
|
  
Yours doesn't either
Harrim | 11/28/06
|
   
Your code does the same thing.
Anton Philidor | 11/28/06
|
    
I disagree
voska | 11/28/06
|
     
So let's say...
Anton Philidor | 11/28/06
|
     
Anton - you want to have to have your cake and eat it....
bportlock | 11/29/06
|
     
Um that's capitolism
voska | 11/29/06
|
     
Open Office
Anton Philidor | 11/29/06
|
   
You have to DO something with your idea to copyright it.
Too Old For IT | 11/29/06
|
  
Re: Doesn't work.
none none | 11/28/06
|
   
Congress used a word...
Anton Philidor | 11/28/06
|
    
Your definition with the caveat...
Anton Philidor | 11/28/06
|
     
Re: Your definition with the caveat...
none none | 11/28/06
|
     
Herein lies the problem!
Logics | 11/30/06
|
 
Copyright instead of Patent?
metajohn@... | 11/28/06
|
 
But where does it stop?
A.Sinic | 11/29/06
|
  
Just my opinion
voska | 11/29/06
|
 
Wow all the techies got a bit touchy
jsjag1 | 11/29/06
|
if patents and copyrights foster genius, where is Mozart?
ionbidon@... | 11/28/06
|

Get informed
frgough | 11/28/06
|
 
Really?
Langalibalene | 11/28/06
|
 
"Marxists", huh?
John L. Ries | 11/28/06
|
  
Health insurance is a scam
reddtigger | 11/28/06
|
   
Responded in the wrong place
John L. Ries | 11/28/06
|
   
What?
jsjag1 | 11/29/06
|
    
Use some logic
voska | 11/29/06
|

Wishing he could still get royalties...
Anton Philidor | 11/28/06
|
 
Think you missed the point
voska | 11/28/06
|
  
Music before Copyright
A.Sinic | 11/29/06
|
   
How's that any different from today
voska | 11/29/06
|

Mozart is...
jt@... | 11/28/06
|
 
RE: Mozart is...
blaze1024 | 11/29/06
|

Dude, go talk to Edison...
No_Ax_to_Grind | 11/28/06
|
Hold on to your lug nuts...
Carrion | 11/28/06
|
My favorite Obvious patent...
astro_z | 11/28/06
|

Excellent find!!
Carrion | 11/28/06
|

Exercising a cat
jt@... | 11/28/06
|

how about a pie chart or training manual
RIAAsucks | 11/28/06
|

Re: My favorite Obvious patent...
none none | 11/28/06
|

If the beam is "invisible" how would the cat see it...
rgranger | 11/28/06
|

Obvious?
notsofast | 11/28/06
|

Great example
jsjag1 | 11/29/06
|

My Favorite
wkranitz@... | 11/29/06
|

Prior Art in third World countries....
Logics | 11/30/06
|
Patent law
bobwinners | 11/28/06
|
a test is necessary - yet loop holes must be plugged
chasster | 11/28/06
|
Is it novel, original? Do people in the field say ...
jt@... | 11/28/06
|
Aside from the Obvious after the fact....
Anton Philidor | 11/28/06
|

...but...
John L. Ries | 11/28/06
|
 
Laws of nature can't be patented.
Anton Philidor | 11/28/06
|
  
Never said they could
John L. Ries | 11/28/06
|
   
Jefferson was the first in charge...
Anton Philidor | 11/29/06
|
    
You're right, he was
John L. Ries | 11/29/06
|
     
Restrictions
Anton Philidor | 11/29/06
|

Re: Aside from the Obvious after the fact....
none none | 11/28/06
|
Patent system is broken
rjcarlson49 | 11/28/06
|
Another step towards ripping off Australia's CSIRO
YuridaMan | 11/28/06
|

Not really
osreinstall | 11/28/06
|
patent is the tech area is sick and distorded
Mectron | 11/28/06
|

yeah right
element13 | 11/28/06
|
Tackle more of the problem.
diane@... | 11/28/06
|
The Original Objective
JelMin | 11/28/06
|
Pardon me, this is not the task of the court.
No_Ax_to_Grind | 11/28/06
|

Court's Job - Interperet Laws
The-Bytemaster | 11/28/06
|
 
Interpret yes, make new law no,
No_Ax_to_Grind | 11/28/06
|
  
Judges can't make new laws
voska | 11/29/06
|
   
In the US, unfortunately, they can.
Anton Philidor | 11/29/06
|

Be careful what you wish for
John L. Ries | 11/28/06
|
 
Regardless of outcome,
No_Ax_to_Grind | 11/28/06
|
  
Then you think software patents in the US should never have existed
Edward Meyers | 11/29/06
|
   
No, I said it is up to Congress. Having reading problems?
No_Ax_to_Grind | 11/29/06
|
    
You have the reading problem
Edward Meyers | 11/29/06
|
  
In general, I agree
John L. Ries | 11/29/06
|

But of Course it is!
mejohnsn | 12/15/06
|
Supreme Court weighs 'obviousness' of patents
turnitup | 11/28/06
|
Possibly
John L. Ries | 11/28/06
|

Insurance forums
jsjag1 | 11/29/06
|
 
The original topic of the thread...
John L. Ries | 11/29/06
|
Obviousness in Patent Cases
mekhongkurt@... | 11/29/06
|
The Problem with Patents
voska | 11/29/06
|
GOOD
CobraA1 | 11/29/06
|
Patents: Obvious problems and solutions
frsharp@... | 11/29/06
|
Something amiss?
frsharp@... | 11/29/06
|
Supreme Court loves to pick battles of their 'liking'
Boot_Agnostic | 11/29/06
|
perpetual motion machine patents
brucewt | 11/30/06
|

I think in the USA, you can't patent perpetual motion machines anymore
CobraA1 | 12/03/06
|
Why have patents?
pcmag@... | 12/05/06
|

Spot the uncreative person in this picture...
DirkBelig | 12/09/06
|
Consumer Psychology
rpitty | 02/10/07
|