On mySimon: Inside the World of Charm City Cakes
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet
TalkBack 1 of 227:
Next »
Finally, a report that actually makes some sense
It's nice to see a report that actually makes some sense. Some very valid key points in this report that I agree with 100%:

You can't drive a Linux implementation based on 'you love Linux' or 'you hate Microsoft'."

Zealots take note of the above please...

"the real issue is how to keep [Windows] secure in the first place--and the cost associated with that".

The cost of which will come down if:

Vile believes the Windows security concerns are valid - especially that the costs for securing the operating system are high. Still, he notes Windows is improving, pointing to security enhancement with Service Pack 2, for example. "There are less and less reasons to move away from Windows as time goes on," he said.

The old chestnut of security IS being addressed. How long will it be before Windows security is on par with any other OS? - Not long if this report is anything to go by.

"If Linux were on 50 per cent of desktops it would become much bigger target [for hackers and virus writers]."

How many times has this point been raised? Would its [linux] perceived security be as high once the hackers got a good hold on it?

"We don't anticipate some big tipping point where Linux will go to significant penetration. It will happen gradually. And it will be limited to the exception rather than the rule."

Which is exactly what most of us that are not Linux fanatics have been saying on ZDNet for quite some time now.

According to Quocirca's Vile, many of the survey respondents who lacked hands-on Linux experience "tend to think [Linux] is only usable for power users, people who are highly [computer] literate. [But] it's completely opposite--that's the last person to deploy Linux to."

So don't deploy Linux to anyone who is experienced or computer literate? Surely this is incorrect. Linux is no harder or easier than Windows to use, now that Gnome and KDE are making the X environment so similar to Windows.
Posted by: Scrat   Posted on: 04/06/05 You are currently: a Guest | Members login | Terms of Use

Alert moderator to an offensive message

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

Finally, a report that actually makes some sense  Scrat | 04/06/05
Excellent post  Loverock Davidson | 04/06/05
I thought it sucked  Jeff Spicoli | 04/06/05
JavaScript  Loverock Davidson | 04/06/05
I think Firefox can slap down javascript pretty good anyway  Jeff Spicoli | 04/06/05
LIAR! LIAR!  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
Now now  Loverock Davidson | 04/06/05
Diminishing returns  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
Linsux will reach 99% of desktops! BWAHAHAHA!!!  Jeff Spicoli | 04/06/05
You are dreaming... happy  balsover | 04/06/05
RE: Now now  richdave | 04/10/05
Re: Now now  Moxie_z | 04/11/05
Noo ..  Ardian Daka | 04/06/05
High availability does not equal high vulnerability.  The King's Servant | 04/06/05
TC0 vs. TCO - nice!  Hugh Jass | 04/06/05
It's a little difficult to prove  balsover | 04/06/05
How about using logic?  arh_z | 04/07/05
using words like linsux...  balsover | 04/06/05
Many hackers are M$ haters.  jjon2121 | 04/07/05
I really hate to disagree...  Real World | 04/06/05
Novell Linux Desktop  AppealsIT | 04/06/05
A point to ponder.  The King's Servant | 04/06/05
maybe true for some folks over 30.  wimbo_z | 04/06/05
Windows loser  Jeff Spicoli | 04/06/05
Reminder from the Yankee study yesterday.  Anton Philidor | 04/06/05
Yup  Sheeva | 04/06/05
It's just good....  rob.astleford@... | 04/06/05
Good policy summary:  Anton Philidor | 04/06/05
I don't think I got your point.  The King's Servant | 04/06/05
Exactly right.  Anton Philidor | 04/07/05
One thing...  FreeBSD | 04/06/05
you forget...  jdahs@... | 04/06/05
Popularity/Number of users is only ONE part of the  Laff | 04/06/05
Please explain?  Richard Flude | 04/06/05
Getting personal?  Scrat | 04/07/05
It is perfectly acceptable  Richard Flude | 04/07/05
IT pros consider desktop Linux  Loverock Davidson | 04/06/05
That's funny  Michael Kelly | 04/06/05
Not so funny  Loverock Davidson | 04/06/05
I think you are full of it.  Linux User 147560 | 04/06/05
No you are  Loverock Davidson | 04/06/05
This is what happens  The King's Servant | 04/06/05
RE: No you are  Linux User 147560 | 04/06/05
Re: No you are  richdave | 04/10/05
Which ones?  balsover | 04/06/05
Linsux weenies, eh Rockhead?  Jeff Spicoli | 04/06/05
Then you should tell that...  Loverock Davidson | 04/06/05
They aren't!  Jeff Spicoli | 04/06/05
What are you calling 'server' services?  Hugh Jass | 04/06/05
huh?  wimbo_z | 04/06/05
Until Linux becomes user friendly, it won't be adopted en mass.  realitycheck101 | 04/06/05
Re: won't be adpoted en mass  alterego_z | 04/06/05
You case is not typical  balsover | 04/06/05
User Friendly Linux Exists!  Flexsxan | 04/06/05
Linux is as user friendly as Windows  basilf@... | 04/06/05
As a Linux fan...  bargeemike | 04/06/05
RE: As a Linux fan...  richdave | 04/06/05
Perhaps when considerreing Linux for the consumer  Laff | 04/07/05
EW: Perhaps when considerreing Linux for the consumer  richdave | 04/07/05
Mandrake is supposed to be more user friendly than Suse or RH  balsover | 04/06/05
RE: Mandrake is supposed to be more user friendly than Suse or RH  richdave | 04/07/05
RE: Unfortunately many folks desire that Linux stay a "geeks" O/S  wimbo_z | 04/06/05
forgot the transitional.  wimbo_z | 04/06/05
What have you actually tried?  masinick@... | 04/06/05
Repeating the Big Lie  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
Then please  Real World | 04/06/05
Why should I?  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
It's the difference  Real World | 04/06/05
Have you stopped beating your wife yet?  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
Has your wife stopped beating you?  Real World | 04/06/05
Muscial chairs  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
RE musical charis  Real World | 04/06/05
Finally  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
No, I never beat her(nt)  ShadeTree | 04/06/05
Why should he?  Chad_z | 04/06/05
What about Apache?  Jeff Spicoli | 04/06/05
Apache example  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
Same old out dated tired rant!  ShadeTree | 04/06/05
Did you miss the "a Microsoft-funded study" part, Shade?  Judas I. | 04/06/05
Did you miss the data behind the study?  ShadeTree | 04/06/05
Did you miss the data supplied by the foxes?  Judas I. | 04/06/05
Similar to their campaign against OOo.  nucrash | 04/06/05
Re: Did you miss the data behind the study?  none none | 04/06/05
Ever heard the term  lengua99 | 04/30/05
other reason:  jdahs@... | 04/06/05
Carefull Fudster!  ShadeTree | 04/06/05
El Wrongo  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
agreed  Jeff Spicoli | 04/06/05
So it is your contention that Linux ...  ShadeTree | 04/06/05
Alleged  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
Actually Microsoft ...  ShadeTree | 04/06/05
Not sure about M$  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
Anti-Trust can be criminal or Civil  ShadeTree | 04/06/05
Shade, anti-trust is only civil.  Anton Philidor | 04/06/05
RE: Anton  ShadeTree | 04/06/05
Thanks.  Anton Philidor | 04/06/05
Can't you ever not grasp at those straws?  Jeff Spicoli | 04/06/05
There are criminal statutes...  ShadeTree | 04/06/05
Thank you for acknowledging you are wrong!  ShadeTree | 04/06/05
Motivations  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
Easier...  thutchins | 04/06/05
Re: El Wrongo  none none | 04/06/05
No FUD, only what is  Jeff Spicoli | 04/06/05
pocket PC is pretty pathetic  Monkey_MCSE | 04/06/05
pocket PC is pretty pathetic  RannXerox | 04/06/05
my Palm phone made in 2000  kingofnerds@... | 04/06/05
Hold on a second there, Hoss.  Yen_z | 04/06/05
Windows CE versus Windows embedded  ShadeTree | 04/06/05
Take a look:  Yen_z | 04/06/05
Marketshare does present a prime target  FilledOut | 04/06/05
Motivations  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
You really blew it here!  ShadeTree | 04/06/05
Hard to say  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
No room to wiggle here  ShadeTree | 04/06/05
Criminal behavior  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
Wow, memory lane here!  Scrat | 04/06/05
RE: Wow, memory lane here!  Linux User 147560 | 04/06/05
Facts  NonZealot | 04/06/05
Wow  IT Scion | 04/06/05
Actual good points.  Anton Philidor | 04/06/05
Also people love to hate MS  voska | 04/06/05
Not true!  ShadeTree | 04/06/05
Right....  nucrash | 04/06/05
Maybe, but...  Real World | 04/06/05
The problem is  michael-t | 04/06/05
The real deal  ShadeTree | 04/06/05
A small vocal minority is all it takes  voska | 04/06/05
Actually...  Spikey_Mike | 04/06/05
respect, don't make me laugh try loathing!  Network Support | 05/31/05
Nice try.  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
More mindnumming drone! happy  NonZealot | 04/06/05
Icky Worms  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
I thought you were a scientist?  ShadeTree | 04/06/05
Science is as Science does  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
You did answer each claim but ...  ShadeTree | 04/06/05
Lies, Damn Lies, and Statistics  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
The web site links are at least an attempt at proof ...  ShadeTree | 04/06/05
Opinion noted  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
Not entirely true, I'd say 98%  voska | 04/06/05
Facts????  chemist109 | 04/06/05
Fact # 1 destroyed  Richard Flude | 04/06/05
Richard, we've talked about this!  NonZealot | 04/06/05
Yes we have  Richard Flude | 04/06/05
We could go back and forth  NonZealot | 04/06/05
And we will  Richard Flude | 04/06/05
Okay, let's!  NonZealot | 04/06/05
noexec is easy with software restriction policy  NonZealot | 04/06/05
And as we talk, so do others  Richard Flude | 04/08/05
It's the money shot  rob.astleford@... | 04/06/05
Ex-cell-ent  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
Not FUD, Simple statistics  balsover | 04/06/05
LIAR! LIAR!  Roger Ramjet | 04/07/05
Turning Tides  jjanks | 04/06/05
I see it differently  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
IT pros consider NO desktop  j.m.galvin | 04/06/05
Microsoft's worst fear  Jeff Spicoli | 04/06/05
Not necessarily  j.m.galvin | 04/06/05
Yabbut  Yagotta B. Kidding | 04/06/05
Nature of business  j.m.galvin | 04/06/05
one problem i've run into.  Monkey_MCSE | 04/06/05
Don't many *nix packages use the same licensing model  balsover | 04/06/05
Don't know  j.m.galvin | 04/07/05
Yes, you are right  Roger Ramjet | 04/06/05
A sleeper ...  George Mitchell | 04/06/05
One other interesting thing in article  j.m.galvin | 04/06/05
This is really stating the OBVIOUS  michael-t | 04/06/05
yeah I have to say I've moved this way  hipparchus2000 | 04/07/05
and the point is?????????  Power User | 04/07/05
so you're calling a web site a web service  hipparchus2000 | 04/07/05
Another very biased analysis  pa2004 | 04/06/05
the real reason  dapopster | 04/06/05
Is it in their interests?  dbrimlow | 04/06/05
linux  cknapp151 | 04/06/05
I think you better get a spellchecker before I take your posts seriously  Nobody_really | 04/06/05
Has it occurred to you...  balsover | 04/06/05
So you're saying:  Real World | 04/07/05
heh  cknapp151 | 04/07/05
not very  Power User | 04/07/05
unix  cknapp151 | 04/07/05
Give me a break....  charlesgoff | 04/06/05
wha...  cknapp151 | 04/06/05
IT pros consider desktop Linux  spotvin | 04/06/05
Alternatives to Windows & Linux ...  mwagner@... | 04/06/05
maybe, but who's interoperability are we talking about?  el1jones | 04/06/05
A new study ? Kidding ?  johns_z | 04/06/05
is it??  Monkey_MCSE | 04/06/05
I was a tech once ...  George Mitchell | 04/06/05
C64's will make a huge comeback  IT Scion | 04/07/05
almost right  Power User | 04/07/05
This just isn't true ...  mwagner@... | 04/06/05
Mixed Environments Say Otherwise  taliesinangelus | 04/06/05
Mike Cox.... ist that you?(nt)  el1jones | 04/06/05
reMike Cox.... ist that you?  Llandros Loressin | 04/07/05
You just sound so much like an IT 'pro'  michael-t | 04/06/05
Tech? I think not yer Elmer FUD  Network Support | 06/01/05
Linux versus Windows ...  mwagner@... | 04/06/05
Generally good advice, considering its assumptions ...  George Mitchell | 04/06/05
Not User Friendly?!  soulcircus | 04/06/05
NO, they are NOT user-friendly ...  mwagner@... | 04/06/05
Buying pre installed is easy if you're big enough  j.m.galvin | 04/06/05
WinDOS no better  hulse_kevin | 04/06/05
First Tier OEM....  nucrash | 04/06/05
Forgot to back up my rant  nucrash | 04/06/05
such a load of bull  Network Support | 06/01/05
my point exactly  Power User | 04/07/05
like a pro?  Monkey_MCSE | 04/07/05
linux desktop growth question  mgarfein | 04/06/05
Linux less secure than Windows?  soulcircus | 04/06/05
There si no virus which can "own" a Linux system....  Jomo_z | 04/06/05
Nonsense  balsover | 04/06/05
The difference between Windows and Linux is ...  George Mitchell | 04/07/05
true but!!!!!!!!!!!!!  Power User | 04/07/05
Fork Bomb.  IT Scion | 04/07/05
You will continue to hear "Linux is good for..... BUT...  chiishen | 04/06/05
'Experts' continue to enlighten the poor masses ...  michael-t | 04/06/05
More bs from the IT 'Pros' and other hilarious stories  michael-t | 04/06/05
Interesting notion of "power user"  John L. Ries | 04/06/05
you and your common sense john  Monkey_MCSE | 04/06/05
a true power user does in one line of SQL  hipparchus2000 | 04/07/05
Office network  Lynn110 | 04/06/05
Reverse securology  rod_rey | 04/07/05
Lamers Wake Up  jkjel1 | 04/08/05
Compare Linux to Mac's  rkhalloran | 04/08/05
I agree  hipparchus2000 | 04/08/05
Desktop Linux  jkeels | 04/09/05
Screw IT pros  mlindl | 04/10/05
Linux on the Desktop  hburff | 04/14/05

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement
Premier Vendor Content Whitepapers, webcasts & resources from our Power Center Sponsors
Reduce risk. Reduce complexity. Increase reliability.
A simplified IT environment isn't just less complex. It's also more reliable. Standardize on a single Linux platform with SUSE Linux Enterprise from Novell, and get the world's most interoperable Linux
Learn more >>
New Online Dashboard for IT Leaders
Read about top issues IT decision-makers face every day, plus get cost-effective solutions to real-life IT problems.
Learn more >>
Save time with automated shipping solutions
The Business Essentials Guide provides you useful tools and templates to help grow your business and save you time with automated shipping solutions.
Visit the UPS Business Essentials Guide
Keep Up With The Latest In Document Management with The DocuMentor.
Doc delivers the scoop on today's enterprise content management, printer maintenance, and all other issues related to document management. It's the DocuMentor Blog.
Learn more >>
Business Value of Windows Server 2008 R2 Hyper-V and Live Migration.
Today's IT departments are under increasing pressure to manage and support expanding computer resources while reducing costs. See how Windows Server 2008 R2 is making this process seamless.
Click to download >>
Microsoft Dynamics CRM Online - Free Six-Month Trial for Eligible Organizations
Microsoft Dynamics CRM Online provides fast online access, simple contact management and better sales performance for a low monthly cost - the best value on the market today.
Learn more about the free, six-month trial offer >>

SmartPlanet

Click Here