On CBS MoneyWatch: How to Haggle on Your Rent
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet
TalkBack 7 of 25:
Next »
« Previous
The goal is laudable, the solution unworkable
Details on how the system would work are missing from McCain's legislation and are left to the center and ISPs.

I understand why the details are missing, I don't see technology as being available to actually do this.

1) Who decides what is offensive. We all know the black and white ones, what about borderline? If I subscribe to online Teen magazine for my daughter, am I a criminal?
2) Tens of Millions of images. I don't envy the team who has to scan, tag, identify, post the hexcode checksums that can be tracked. How about the 10-100K new one's per day. We don't have the technology for a computer to decide which are good and which are evil.
3) Any time you send a picture using AOL, for example, it has to link to the database, after generating the checksum, to verify it isn't illegal content? How long will page loads take when 30+ images are present. Do they have a server farm to handle 100 billion hits per day? Does every ISP/application/service of any sort have to keep a local 100 gigabyte database of illegal checksums?

I like the provisions to increase the sentence for anyone who commits the crime using the internet, but monitoring all images in realtime is not going to fly.

Hopefully, someone with technical know how can propose a system that could work?

TripleII
Posted by: TripleII   Posted on: 02/07/07 You are currently: a Guest | Members login | Terms of Use

Alert moderator to an offensive message

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

What the frack?  Technocrat@... | 02/07/07
one small step for...  shraven | 02/07/07
Lascivious images? Are they kidding?  KaplanMike | 02/07/07
Worse Than China  ceh4702 | 02/07/07
Grandma Jailed for Emailed Baby Pix  KTHernandez | 02/07/07
What prevents false accusations?  kalatuckar@... | 02/07/07
The goal is laudable, the solution unworkable  TripleII | 02/07/07
Guilty until proved innocent?  clockmendergb@... | 02/07/07
Goal is NOT laudable!  Technocrat@... | 02/08/07
Not, not that goal  TripleII | 02/08/07
Ahhh, I see.  Technocrat@... | 02/11/07
Guess the Senator's never heard of PGP. (nt)  James T. Kirk | 02/07/07
Goodbye Michelangelo, Donatello, and the rest  ersatz | 02/07/07
Too much 24?  d.esposito@... | 02/07/07
Civics (not the nip car) and Government  a.techno.geek | 02/07/07
image surveillance  vger_z | 02/07/07
Inane thoughts  deowll | 02/07/07
SAFE+McCain = Orwell  jackdrew@... | 02/07/07
As if....  dojunmarn | 02/07/07
And to think I WAS a McCain supporter!  Jeff Hayes | 02/07/07
Hitler is alive and well  Ole Man | 02/07/07
Well said and all too true.  Technocrat@... | 02/08/07
What about doing a recall vote on these ID10ts?  Mr_Dave | 02/08/07
Be Careful  mb96001@... | 02/08/07
Danish Cartoons??!!!  rorshie | 02/09/07

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Meet Doc

  • Here to help you with your Document Management Needs
  • Doc is an enigma. Born to a Russian ballerina and a German electrical engineer, he grew up in various locations in the United States. He’s seen the insides of more brands, versions, and generations of printer and printer-related hardware than almost anyone.
  • To learn more about this mysterious figure check out his blog on ZDNet and his Workspace on TechRepublic. You’ll be glad you did.
  • Produced by
    ZDNet and