On mySimon: Samsung 55" LED TV
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet
TalkBack 30 of 738:
Next »
« Previous
You're soaking in it
Considering things like ftp, e-mail and http all use peer to peer
networks. It's important to safeguard these technologies and
stimulate their development.
Posted by: tic swayback   Posted on: 06/27/05 You are currently: a Guest | Members login | Terms of Use
Reply to Story Reply to Message

Alert moderator to an offensive message

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

Goodbye innovation  john@... | 06/27/05
You got it!  Tim Patterson | 06/27/05
The System Suck's  IceTheNet@... | 06/27/05
Pure BABBLE...  Wolfie2K3 | 06/27/05
Major Loss argument additions  jheine | 06/27/05
Thank You  hellooothere | 06/27/05
bad decisions  danieleoneil@... | 06/28/05
Brainwashing at it's finest  maniac682001@... | 07/25/05
system sucks  espodad | 06/27/05
Good Bye America...  low-life | 06/27/05
see ya..wouldn't wanna be ya.  htotten | 06/28/05
This might be good for open source.  DonnieBoy | 06/27/05
I think so too  tic swayback | 06/27/05
one other little thing  jgolini | 06/27/05
Plenty of pro-bono help  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Declaring Bankruptcy  M2150ad@... | 06/27/05
bankruptcy  seegs | 11/14/05
Better if they promote  htotten | 06/28/05
If the software has a name and a website...  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
If nobody is profiting from the software, nothing you can do.  DonnieBoy | 06/27/05
There is nothing innovative about being a crook.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/27/05
No_Ax, have you ever used P2P?  Reverend MacFellow | 06/27/05
Sure, but not for illegal use.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/27/05
What legal things?  Reverend MacFellow | 06/27/05
Lots of legal things  tic swayback | 06/27/05
I've used Bit Torrent to get legal files all the time  voska | 06/27/05
Same Old Same old  richardpor | 06/27/05
why else would you buy playboy?  voska | 06/27/05
Why buy, unless for the articles?  Spoon Jabber | 06/27/05
You're soaking in it  tic swayback | 06/27/05
HTTP and Email P2P?  archnova79 | 06/27/05
It's arguable  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Actually both are  maldain | 06/27/05
How are you guys defining P2P?  The King's Servant | 06/27/05
No_Ax Used To Tape Cassettes And LPs And Give Them To Friends  itanalyst | 06/27/05
...and now, you and I won't be able to anymore.  The King's Servant | 06/27/05
However  Spoon Jabber | 06/27/05
and that means what  wexwimpy@... | 06/27/05
According to the article...  Spoon Jabber | 06/27/05
good for lawyers  jgolini | 06/27/05
RE: ...and now, you and I won't be able to anymore.  nightshade0143 | 06/27/05
You simply do not understand...  BitTwiddler | 06/27/05
DON'T CALL ME A LIAR!  macbill | 06/27/05
Up to your armpits, then  AbsolutelyNot | 06/27/05
But it's OK that the music publishers steal royalties  jmw@... | 06/27/05
Sure there is  Yagotta B. Kidding | 06/27/05
EXACTLY... try telling that to Microsoft  MacCanuck | 06/27/05
How Dare You Call US CROOK's  IceTheNet@... | 06/27/05
Bad examples  tic swayback | 06/27/05
BAD 2 U  IceTheNet@... | 06/27/05
Bought and paid for  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Paying Fees.  iwish40 | 06/27/05
Wrong  AbsolutelyNot | 06/27/05
Yep  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Another thing on movies  voska | 06/27/05
No, only if...  Spoon Jabber | 06/27/05
A friend of mine owned record store  voska | 06/27/05
USA v Canada?  Spoon Jabber | 06/27/05
I believe you're supposed to pay  tic swayback | 06/27/05
If you are a business, you are liable.  The King's Servant | 06/27/05
Radio stations are paid to play songs  voska | 06/27/05
Technically, no, they're not  tic swayback | 06/27/05
I just want to add a little more  IceTheNet@... | 06/27/05
You are right, you are not a crook...  Colonel_Panic | 06/27/05
Thanks!  brble | 06/27/05
I don't like ShiceOnTheNet, he showed up...  Colonel_Panic | 06/27/05
It's easy...  Wolfie2K3 | 06/27/05
You pay for Radio and TV indirectly  jescocom | 06/28/05
You are kidding right?  webenerds | 07/10/05
please explain  mejustme | 07/14/05
Well said, No_Ax_to_Grind  labarker | 06/27/05
RE: There is nothing innovative about being a crook.  nightshade0143 | 06/27/05
If p2p is wrong - aren't gun makers  artisan1 | 06/29/05
Well Put!  maniac682001@... | 07/26/05
Protect the Owner  irazisme | 06/27/05
You obviously don't understand the industry  AbsolutelyNot | 06/27/05
I don't Understand . . .  Sheeva | 06/27/05
Using P2P for distributing your own material  AbsolutelyNot | 06/27/05
Thought Michael Jackson and Paul McCartney...  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
Like a frog in a pot of water...  Lopar-XL | 06/27/05
Goodbye Innovation  tvaughn@... | 06/27/05
P2P??  dollar95 | 06/27/05
FYI  Sheeva | 06/27/05
Not quite  tic swayback | 06/27/05
bye bye music sales  PatrynXX | 06/27/05
I hear ya, bought more CD during Napster's Time  voska | 06/27/05
Innovation? You are kidding Clyde  osreinstall | 06/27/05
File Swap Decision...Is a Negative  estarnes4@... | 06/27/05
swapping  samm_z | 06/27/05
Supreme Court Re: file-swapping  mclehr@... | 06/27/05
court rulling on P2P  warogren@... | 06/27/05
Whatever!  FireWire_z | 06/28/05
sharing  jdnagle | 06/29/05
SCOTUS hates America?  Tim Patterson | 06/27/05
They LOVE freedom  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/27/05
Sort of  tic swayback | 06/27/05
I agree completely...  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/27/05
Then shouldn't they restrict telephones?  Reverend MacFellow | 06/27/05
Restrict the way they're promoted  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Don't cry to me, tell the courts.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/27/05
No blinders  gary.douglas@... | 06/27/05
Great  vferrara | 06/27/05
Get your bad guys straigth!  Wolfie2K3 | 06/27/05
You are blind Bit  Tim Patterson | 06/27/05
Read the decision  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Affirmative Steps  bhartman36 | 06/27/05
Don't forget this part  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Evidence of Intent  bhartman36 | 06/27/05
Funny thing...  Wolfie2K3 | 06/27/05
Those you Forget History.....  einker@... | 06/27/05
Perhaps a revisiting is in order  tic swayback | 06/27/05
here! here!....well Said  twinkler@... | 06/27/05
Imminent Domain - demise of small business?  tomh5480 | 06/27/05
No such decision was rendered...  DAB_z | 06/27/05
So you agree, albeit guardedly so  tomh5480 | 06/27/05
Why do you feel you have the right to steal someone's labor?  rwilson@... | 06/27/05
Can you read?  Tim Patterson | 06/27/05
Tiz All About the Money  Hexer | 06/29/05
Message has been deleted.  RIAAsucks | 06/27/05
THIS Generation?  macbill | 06/27/05
Get off your high-horse.  lalogos | 06/27/05
Dismounted but still riding....  kejones | 06/27/05
That is sound thinking.  OldMarine | 06/29/05
The real key  rapson | 06/27/05
Hmmm, I don't think it will be hard at all.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/27/05
Missing the point  tic swayback | 06/27/05
I am not saying the software...  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/27/05
Which has nothing to do with this decision  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Harder than you think  AbsolutelyNot | 06/27/05
RE: Harder than you think  nightshade0143 | 06/27/05
Showing intent....  taskman | 06/27/05
Promotion, not intent  tic swayback | 06/27/05
I believe the OEMs do that  voska | 06/27/05
Big Box Stores and Intent  rwilson@... | 06/27/05
RE: The real key  DalyDose | 06/27/05
How is that any different?  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Would you then also agree . . .  rwilson@... | 06/27/05
tool v. user  Gray2 | 06/27/05
That's it  rapson | 06/27/05
tool v. user part II  OhioCopTech | 06/27/05
The real key  none none | 06/27/05
not a blank check, just bankrupcy  jgolini | 06/27/05
Oh calm down already  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Not even that  Yagotta B. Kidding | 06/27/05
It's not about P2P Technology per se  bobweber | 06/27/05
Read the decision here  tic swayback | 06/27/05
5 facist and 4 goodguys!  Reverend MacFellow | 06/27/05
Which is which?  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Just for the record...  decopiano | 06/27/05
I wonder if they're the same 5 who overlooked...  HypnoToad | 06/27/05
Actually  bradb@... | 06/27/05
Just so you know  vferrara | 06/27/05
Leftist facist!  An_Axe_to_Grind | 06/27/05
5 facist and 4 goodguys!  deanoa | 06/29/05
that's the american way  maniac682001@... | 07/26/05
"Gropster"  jencykelly | 06/27/05
Responsibility  telephonics | 06/27/05
Not so much aiding as willfully promoting  tic swayback | 06/27/05
The telephone companies are really the guilty ones then!  Reverend MacFellow | 06/27/05
Does your phone company promote infringement?  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Although I am against this constitutional travesty, if...  Colonel_Panic | 06/27/05
Has nothing to do with the constitution  John L. Ries | 06/28/05
If you think that, then you can't see the bigger picture.  Protector | 06/28/05
Please elaborate (NT)  John L. Ries | 06/28/05
Either toothless or ruthless  wolf5370 | 06/27/05
Off topic: whaddya know, klunqeror actually works as...  Colonel_Panic | 06/27/05
Slippery Slope One more time  BarbieLee | 06/27/05
No slope whatsoever  tic swayback | 06/27/05
What of MS Media Center  voska | 06/27/05
We'll see if there's a lawsuit  tic swayback | 06/27/05
A Different Slope  brunoNYC | 06/27/05
Supreme Court's file-sharing decision: How important?  philpottle@... | 06/27/05
Radio, 1 recording. P2P millions of recordings  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/27/05
Re: Radio, 1 recording. P2P millions of recordings  B.O.F.H. | 06/27/05
There is no difference except  voska | 06/27/05
File Swapping  PaPa51 | 06/27/05
it is if your breakin the law  waylander | 06/27/05
Give me a break  kingdude1 | 06/27/05
Ok  kingdude1 | 06/27/05
Being a musician yourself . . .  rwilson@... | 06/27/05
RDWilson2  BustaSize13inyoass | 06/28/05
Well actually  sirsully | 06/27/05
Actually you buy the content  voska | 06/27/05
an example (and I could be wrong)  Titokhan | 06/27/05
Copying my OWN media!  mclehr@... | 06/27/05
Shouldn't be a problem  tic swayback | 06/27/05
dont forget  webmaxx | 06/27/05
That's why the RIAA sue for making available  voska | 06/27/05
Uncharted waters  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Technically speaking . . .  rwilson@... | 06/27/05
Recording Off the Radio  bhartman36 | 06/27/05
Not like radio at all!!  chumble | 06/29/05
Supreme Court's file-sharing decision: How important? it isn't.  sir_cheats_a_lot | 06/29/05
rights, wrongs and greed  dove-7 | 07/01/05
with everything that happening lately  toxicfreak | 06/27/05
Canada, a good place to live?  Reverend MacFellow | 06/27/05
Don't even think about starting...  Colonel_Panic | 06/27/05
3 little letters for you  Real World | 06/27/05
no kidding  lfagius | 06/27/05
its a matter of point of view  toxicfreak | 06/27/05
Skippy? WTF? I would rather have my...  Colonel_Panic | 06/27/05
GST did nothing of the sort  voska | 06/27/05
That is the US government for ya...  sir_cheats_a_lot | 06/30/05
yes its a excellent place to live  toxicfreak | 06/27/05
yea, keep on going....  lfagius | 06/27/05
I disagree  voska | 06/27/05
Not sure where this place you live is  voska | 06/27/05
Legalities of war are decided by the winner...  fattung@... | 06/27/05
Huh?  maniac682001@... | 07/26/05
canada is good  chowhuahua@... | 06/27/05
Good news!!  Bill Tumbleson | 06/28/05
excellent, yes and no  sir_cheats_a_lot | 06/30/05
This is nonsense  ashraaq_wahab6789 | 06/27/05
There's a question  AbsolutelyNot | 06/27/05
Impossible  rapson | 06/27/05
Sue 'em all!  becksdark | 06/27/05
Go ahead, I'll watch. I need a good laugh  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/27/05
Message has been deleted.  Reverend MacFellow | 06/27/05
Just Like Your Posts Provide A Good Laugh  itanalyst | 06/27/05
:-] (nt)  Colonel_Panic | 06/27/05
Read the freakin' decision!  tic swayback | 06/27/05
I hate to say it  rapson | 06/27/05
Well, you know who's behind all those ignorant posts...  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Ah  rapson | 06/27/05
Just trying to share my pain  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Nah  rapson | 06/27/05
That's more like it  tic swayback | 06/27/05
cell phone  CrazY_UKRaiNiaN | 06/28/05
Sadly...  AbsolutelyNot | 06/27/05
Don't forget Yahoo and Google Groups  pescej | 06/28/05
Being in DENIAL is what's ridiculous !!!  realitycheck101 | 06/27/05
I couldn't agree with you more.  lfagius | 06/27/05
Every DVD comercial use this  Mectron | 06/27/05
Exactly  bradachin@... | 06/27/05
Not so  tic swayback | 06/27/05
MIghty DMCA  Mectron | 06/27/05
Read the Law  voska | 06/27/05
Need to review ownership  voska | 06/27/05
what about Fair Use  wexwimpy@... | 06/30/05
Denial of what?  Mectron | 06/27/05
file swapping..  colin39 | 06/27/05
Yeah!  Reverend MacFellow | 06/27/05
I agree  ashraaq_wahab6789 | 06/27/05
in the imaginary world of make believe  hyhosilver | 06/27/05
Plumbers and electricians  Old Disti | 06/28/05
Supreme Court rules against file-swapping firms  konj | 06/27/05
WRONG  Old Disti | 06/28/05
If you make a profit, be careful what you say.  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
Actions, not thoughts  tic swayback | 06/27/05
a wink and a nudge???  hyhosilver | 06/27/05
No requirement to prevent.  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
no prevention  hyhosilver | 06/27/05
We're safe from requiring steps to prevent infringement.  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
absence of other evidence of intent  hyhosilver | 06/27/05
Yes, mind reading is imprecise.  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
Also, when the court says "clear expression"...  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
That's the key here  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Kids in basements  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
Re: no prevention  none none | 06/27/05
Intent is in the mind.  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
Intent may be in the mind, but behaviors will always nail you!  osreinstall | 06/27/05
The Supreme Court conducted a trial...  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
The getaway car  osreinstall | 06/27/05
I don't know  tic swayback | 06/27/05
You might be right on the cab driver  osreinstall | 06/27/05
In this case, certainly  tic swayback | 06/27/05
I maintained these companies were wrong all along.  osreinstall | 06/27/05
I blame the artist  tmiller_z | 06/27/05
... known as Prince?  PMC-CON | 06/27/05
No you are wrong  Justcauz | 06/27/05
blame who?  InsaneWayne | 06/27/05
P-2-P systems illegal?  metilley@... | 06/27/05
No  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Um, just so you know...  bradb@... | 06/27/05
kaka..  whispers_z | 06/27/05
Why not gun manufacturers?  AbsolutelyNot | 06/27/05
answer...  Nullifidian | 06/27/05
there's a reason  vladsim | 07/02/05
P-2-P systems illegal?  fetter | 06/28/05
Music Copyright  Bill Jones1317 | 06/27/05
Who monitors the Supreme Court for ruling against the Bill of Rights?  j1m2r3@... | 06/27/05
Two things  rapson | 06/27/05
Plus  tic swayback | 06/27/05
That's true  rapson | 06/27/05
Correct  tic swayback | 06/27/05
If I'm not mistaken...  rapson | 06/27/05
Are you really sure...  gfeier | 06/27/05
gfeier: Yes, I am  rapson | 06/28/05
Nope it's three-fourths of states  osreinstall | 06/27/05
Congress monitors the SCOTUS  hyhosilver | 06/27/05
Hello, is anybody home?  vferrara | 06/27/05
Hate to break it to you, but...  bhartman36 | 06/27/05
Charge Car Companies  TrustMe_z | 06/27/05
Interesting consequence  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Result: more s/w development moving offshore  terry flores | 06/27/05
Or  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Small s/w companies can't afford the chance  terry flores | 06/27/05
One more threat among many  tic swayback | 06/27/05
The effect is still the same: loss of jobs  terry flores | 06/27/05
The ruling means NOTHING  Nullifidian | 06/27/05
I totally agree !  ashraaq_wahab6789 | 06/27/05
re: multi-region player  terry flores | 06/27/05
Thankfully im not in the US  ashraaq_wahab6789 | 06/27/05
there will always be pirates  Nullifidian | 06/27/05
fair pricing  tibor_z | 06/27/05
Money means everything  MrPcWizard | 06/27/05
Did anyone else actually RTFR?  Yagotta B. Kidding | 06/27/05
Re: Did anyone else actually RTFR?  none none | 06/27/05
Summary Judgement  hyhosilver | 06/27/05
Actually...  rapson | 06/27/05
Carl, ZDNet speaks with two tongues.  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
Hey... (NT)  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
P2P  bigghead | 06/27/05
are the files marked as copyright protected  VTVagabond | 06/27/05
Consumption purchasing power.  TrustMe_z | 06/27/05
"apparent price fixing"  terry flores | 06/27/05
That's already been shown to be the case  AbsolutelyNot | 06/27/05
Supreme Court rules against file-swapping firms  forbesofindy@... | 06/27/05
Why Stop There?  tigertony | 06/27/05
It's All To Prepare Us For Chinese Rule  itanalyst | 06/27/05
Who Cares, Doesn't Affect Me  itanalyst | 06/27/05
IT may not affect you but it affects others  ashraaq_wahab6789 | 06/27/05
True, Good Point  itanalyst | 06/27/05
Supreme Court rules against file-swapping firms  rick@... | 06/27/05
So Is It Illegal Now To Record Direct TV Digital Music Channels?  itanalyst | 06/27/05
Not illegal to record, but it is illegal to share!  terry flores | 06/27/05
Yes  InsaneWayne | 06/27/05
Responsibility, take 2  hyhosilver | 06/27/05
Sharing music and ideas is not wrong.  Protector | 06/27/05
Another rich get richer law  Berry_z | 06/27/05
Downloading Elvis songs?  AbsolutelyNot | 06/27/05
More of a rich stopping other rich decision  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Legal in Canada  voska | 06/27/05
Its Not about You  mikeybhere | 06/27/05
Yes, Im a copyright owning musician  InsaneWayne | 06/27/05
As a musician, *You* should take action  tibor_z | 06/28/05
I knew it would happen.  osreinstall | 06/27/05
Not that I disagree but  voska | 06/27/05
Re: I knew it would happen.  none none | 06/27/05
Middleman forgot or told the Dream Factory to bugger off.  osreinstall | 06/27/05
copyright holders - due diligence  IAFarm2 | 06/27/05
Digital signing-BIG thumbs down  AbsolutelyNot | 06/27/05
P2P  lucy_z | 06/27/05
Not suprised but could cause a lot of trouble  AmusedByIgnorance | 06/27/05
Blaming others  doc_cotton | 06/29/05
what a joke..  whispers_z | 06/27/05
Done  Protector | 06/27/05
hahaha  whispers_z | 06/27/05
It's Ok Whispers..Most People In This Country Are Too Stupid To Reason With  itanalyst | 06/27/05
And wouldn't know reason if it slapped them.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/27/05
Yes, But Your Name Comes To Mind When You Hear "Robot, Automaton, Brainwash  itanalyst | 06/27/05
They don't sell gun by promoting robbery(NT)  voska | 06/27/05
Happy Birthday to you!  tmccorm | 06/27/05
What the decison does NOT do.  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
more major than that  hyhosilver | 06/27/05
The next big case  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
Re: The next big case  none none | 06/27/05
You do realize Microsoft p2p in Longhorn was reported...  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
Re: You do realize Microsoft p2p in Longhorn was reported...  none none | 06/27/05
Why attack the software maker  Dartan | 06/27/05
Things are a changn'  mikeybhere | 06/27/05
Supreme Court Taking On Barney The Dinosaur  itanalyst | 06/27/05
Sell! Sell! Sell!  PAIGED@... | 06/27/05
They already sold.  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
Keep our regulatory government on target!  krumlauf@... | 06/27/05
Stay on that Soapbox  phi_alpha_nu@... | 06/27/05
edit article  res1djzl | 06/27/05
Entertainment Industry Boycott  Big_Mac_z | 06/27/05
Can I watch? Maybe they'll make a movie???  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/27/05
Good luck with that  tic swayback | 06/27/05
This years box office doing quite well  voska | 06/27/05
So we can blame the Christians?  tic swayback | 06/27/05
"The Passion" box office numbers  cmello | 06/29/05
buying out whole theater showings  doc_cotton | 06/29/05
Buisness as usual  lgump@... | 06/29/05
File-swapping ruling  planeperson@... | 06/27/05
Hey come and sue Emule!  GreatInca | 06/27/05
Bah...  KOS-MOS | 06/27/05
I agree, give it a few weeks...  Colonel_Panic | 06/27/05
Not really fair...  Overcast | 06/27/05
Amen  jrolls | 06/27/05
Canadian Angle  Coldog | 06/30/05
oh ya...  Coldog | 06/30/05
Comparing oranges and apples  HarveC1 | 06/27/05
Yep!  Overcast | 06/27/05
Where is hate what they did....  critique | 06/27/05
You mean like this example?  AbsolutelyNot | 06/27/05
50 caliber rifle example  teknon5 | 06/29/05
verify  doc_cotton | 06/29/05
You have to get a special license to get one.  osreinstall | 06/29/05
Recoil  doc_cotton | 06/29/05
40mm Hand held???  osreinstall | 06/29/05
Have you seen an advertisement claiming this?  Brsmith | 06/30/05
Gun lobby  GFW_z | 06/29/05
I wonder if the USPS will be sued?  teknon5 | 06/29/05
Comparing apples and oranges  l_turn9 | 06/29/05
supreme court  jrolls | 06/27/05
Uh...the decision was unanimous  Stewart Cannon | 06/27/05
Thanks BBQ  bradb@... | 06/27/05
Wonder why?  HarveC1 | 06/29/05
Supreme Court  l_turn9 | 06/29/05
A sad moment in history....  critique | 06/27/05
Back to square one  wrenchit | 06/27/05
Response  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Also, when the court says "clear expression"...  hyhosilver | 06/27/05
Can I say I told you so now.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/27/05
OK another Big Brother aid to the people  Redneck45 | 06/27/05
A reasonable compromise  tic swayback | 06/27/05
General public: Piracy is normal  tic swayback | 06/27/05
lies = misunderstanding, theft = infringement  hyhosilver | 06/27/05
I'll use the Supreme Court to back up my claim  tic swayback | 06/27/05
you are right that infringement is not, by definition, theft  hyhosilver | 06/27/05
Different laws apply  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Most People Use IRC, Newsgroups, Private FTP Servers, VPNs  itanalyst | 06/27/05
You can be stopped  osreinstall | 06/27/05
How will you know its illegal?  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Packet filtering doesn't work like that  voska | 06/27/05
Some ISPs block P2P services  osreinstall | 06/27/05
That's not how it works  voska | 06/28/05
My provider scans for viruses inbound  osreinstall | 06/28/05
I can't teach TCP/IP over this  voska | 06/28/05
Prices come down  osreinstall | 06/28/05
There is someone always looking for perfection.  osreinstall | 06/27/05
Not perfection, just fairness  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Life is not fair  osreinstall | 06/27/05
Wow, ever read Orwell?  tic swayback | 06/27/05
No I saw the movie which is pretty close to the book.  osreinstall | 06/27/05
That's the end of American Ingenuity. It's now completely dead...  BitTwiddler | 06/27/05
re dick u louse  hyhosilver | 06/27/05
American Ingenuity  doc_cotton | 06/29/05
Freedom?  Kezzerdrix | 06/27/05
Yes, Stealing IS Still Ilegal  Bucyruss | 06/27/05
Spot On!  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/27/05
Justice Breyer gave you a good quote, No_Ax  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
Never underestimate the stupidity...  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
nor underestimate the value of publicity  hyhosilver | 06/27/05
No really  voska | 06/27/05
Brainless zealots  Protector | 06/27/05
P2P  4everdigital | 06/29/05
P2P  jolliroger | 06/29/05
Very Well  AC2 | 06/29/05
File swapping = theft?  dallas_38 | 06/29/05
It's not that cut and dry  ebudae@... | 06/29/05
It's not that cut and dry  matthewnicholas1@... | 06/30/05
Legal system is a joke.  whispers_z | 06/29/05
Stealing - Apples & Oranges  mwm_z | 06/29/05
Illegal ???  gourddancer1@... | 06/29/05
An artists point of view  mditlove | 06/29/05
whatever..  whispers_z | 06/29/05
Copyright  mditlove | 06/29/05
The real issue...  vercan | 06/29/05
Music  doc_cotton | 06/29/05
An artist's point of view  elkabong453 | 06/29/05
Simple analogy  Quixotic | 06/29/05
Yes, Stealing IS Still Ilegal BUT!!!  elkabong453 | 06/29/05
Loopholes in this law  Listener_z@... | 06/29/05
Coming to a library near you! The feds and RIAA  Shackster | 06/29/05
Stealing  thisis50 | 06/29/05
Make Music Industry go after REAL thieves.  im_rrp | 06/29/05
p2p shearing  adrburt | 06/29/05
File Swapping  a2cntryboy | 06/29/05
P2P  Horhai1 | 06/29/05
This is not right!...  dpet | 06/29/05
file copying  swc@... | 06/30/05
What????  MrPcWizard | 06/30/05
But so is price fixing  AZson | 06/30/05
You're completely WRONG !!  TheRealPauper | 06/30/05
Supreme Court rules against file-swapping firms  welchb | 06/30/05
killing is illegal. selling weapons ain't  liviutza | 06/30/05
WRONG!!!  JRD_z | 06/30/05
Hey  efox575 | 06/30/05
Copying music IS illegal, but...  allen_n | 06/30/05
I hear ya  efox575 | 07/01/05
yes stealing is still illegal, but is it stealing?  ankhor | 07/01/05
Black 'n white world  Rich_M | 07/01/05
Yes and No...  vashthestampede | 07/01/05
Bucyruss; I second the motion  ronfour@... | 07/02/05
Supreme Court Really Steps In It  talontamer | 06/27/05
Poor analogy, even worse post.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/27/05
Over and over  rapson | 06/27/05
shouldn?t you be worried?  dpet | 06/30/05
Great example  krumlauf@... | 06/27/05
Thank You  mwm_z | 06/29/05
Supreme Court Really Steps In It  doc_cotton | 06/29/05
File Swapping  zonkjr@... | 06/27/05
not what justices said  twinkler@... | 06/27/05
Only In America Eh! ! ! !  rolav@... | 06/27/05
But..  YourMedication | 06/27/05
Builder of highways now responsible for all acts that use it  ejhonda | 06/27/05
gun makers were exempted decades ago  lfagius | 06/27/05
Computer makers responsible also!!  gourddancer1@... | 06/29/05
What's Next?  jks22835 | 06/27/05
technically, some of those are illegal acts  lfagius | 06/27/05
No Surprises  Stewart Cannon | 06/27/05
Read the ruling...  raisch | 06/27/05
p2p  Horhai1 | 06/29/05
wont stop the majority  ben4022 | 06/27/05
STOP with the useless analogies!!!  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/27/05
Piracy robs people of their rightful earnings  labarker | 06/27/05
But that never stops the crooks...  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/27/05
Hear hear!  tic swayback | 06/27/05
People don't have a choice. The devil made me do it.  osreinstall | 06/27/05
Makes no difference to most artists  tic swayback | 06/27/05
I saw that argument before.  osreinstall | 06/27/05
Glad to see you agree it goes both ways  tic swayback | 06/27/05
But that is his fault  osreinstall | 06/27/05
No asked granny to give her life savings away  voska | 06/28/05
You have a victim mentality  osreinstall | 06/28/05
Yes that is correct  voska | 06/28/05
Some good points  osreinstall | 06/28/05
Re: Hear hear!  none none | 06/27/05
GIVE US A BREAK PIRACY HAS BEEN AROUND FOR YEARS.  wildcat_z | 06/27/05
Bad News for Technology Innovation  John_LI_IT_Guy | 06/27/05
Nothing innovative in being a crook.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/27/05
Supreme crap DECISION!!!  jamesmaxxx@... | 06/27/05
Edgar BronfMORON  nottheusual1 | 06/27/05
Supreme Court Is So Old, Do They Even Know What The Internet Is?  itanalyst | 06/27/05
May you live to be so old...  John L. Ries | 06/28/05
Stop With The Analogies, Those Of Us With Intelligence Know Other Channels  itanalyst | 06/27/05
Best of luck finding us  NoDogs | 06/27/05
other channels  CheeseToast | 06/27/05
file sharing  okluckyme | 06/27/05
China To Buy Microsoft?  itanalyst | 06/27/05
Dear MPAA  itanalyst | 06/27/05
You should have call it DEATH TO MPAA  Mectron | 06/27/05
Cloud with a silver lining ?  solaris_z | 06/27/05
ruling against file swapping  cdarbyc | 06/27/05
Hilary Rosen responds  tic swayback | 06/27/05
I'm stunned  bradb@... | 06/27/05
Hilary has wised up  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Maybe that's why she left.  Anton Philidor | 06/27/05
Extension of legal precedent  jefmud | 06/27/05
Copyright infringement is illegal  bammike | 06/27/05
Yea right..You must be a rich musician  wise-eyes@... | 06/27/05
where the money REALLY goes  InsaneWayne | 06/27/05
MPAA/RIAA are criminal in ALL they activities  Mectron | 06/27/05
Musicians  Gonzo_z | 06/27/05
You're right, Corporations don't care though  voska | 06/28/05
Say hello to Grokster.de, EMule.es, LimeWire.ru  James T. Kirk | 06/27/05
Makes you wonder....  Stu_z | 06/27/05
opens up a can o' worms  kelliman | 06/27/05
opens up a can o'worms  tellinitlikeitis | 06/29/05
Just another Law  Headspin | 06/27/05
Supreme Court's CRAP DECISION!!!  jamesmaxxx@... | 06/27/05
court ruling  tom.farrell3@... | 06/27/05
Word Up  rgarman | 06/27/05
long range effect  jgolini | 06/27/05
Home of the Brave  M2150ad@... | 06/27/05
illegal to share?  Julie8x | 06/27/05
Yes  InsaneWayne | 06/27/05
file-swapping firms  dld1701 | 06/27/05
Who really gets the money - not the artists!  papatator | 06/27/05
Nirvana's Frist Producer  InsaneWayne | 06/27/05
winmx  capt70@... | 06/27/05
Re:how will it affect winmx users?  ashraaq_wahab6789 | 06/28/05
MP3  Dark Warrior | 06/27/05
Here you go  tic swayback | 06/27/05
Supreme Court rules against file-swapping firms  Jantoo1 | 06/27/05
file swapping  wildcat_z | 06/27/05
misinformed? click here  InsaneWayne | 06/27/05
i cant believe it  wildcat_z | 06/27/05
What a Load of Bull...  jima_z | 06/27/05
Ruling against P to P file sharing  texasphoneman@... | 06/27/05
It's stealing, stupid!  jjworleyeoe | 06/27/05
Ridiculous  mike@... | 06/27/05
spiraling...spiraling...  d2r4 | 06/27/05
Supreme Court Ruling  deanhami2001@... | 06/27/05
All that matters is the second decision  emcee_z | 06/27/05
I don't support ilegal copying  79spitfire | 06/27/05
very true  ashraaq_wahab6789 | 06/28/05
Yea, I read it  79spitfire | 06/29/05
Peer to Peer  vorlon007@... | 06/27/05
want to buy a cd burner.. cheep  wise-eyes@... | 06/28/05
File Swapping  wise-eyes@... | 06/27/05
They should shut down all telephone lines!  An_Axe_to_Grind | 06/27/05
Let's see where this goes  CheeseToast | 06/27/05
doesnt go far....  InsaneWayne | 06/27/05
Stop Buying Music !!!and they will think twice  wise-eyes@... | 06/27/05
Boycotting  InsaneWayne | 06/27/05
And Furthermore  wise-eyes@... | 06/28/05
wont need these either  wise-eyes@... | 06/28/05
Boycot  benf_z | 06/29/05
Bars illegal too?  RSBaxter | 06/27/05
BMI sueing bars  InsaneWayne | 06/27/05
You are right under certain circumstances  osreinstall | 06/27/05
See ya'll I'm moving to my island  Squawkbox | 06/27/05
And here is MY ISLAND  Squawkbox | 06/27/05
Supremes Sing a Song of Woe for Individual Rights and Freedoms  codewarrior.wins@... | 06/27/05
Is of zero importance.  KOS-MOS | 06/27/05
Supreme Court?  Gonzo_z | 06/27/05
Right  wise-eyes@... | 06/28/05
Then road builders are murderers...  darkside@... | 06/28/05
Road engineer assassins...  Fred Fredrickson | 06/28/05
"The Supremes" got this one right!  bryan.k.donnelly@... | 06/28/05
what about guns and NRA?  benitodarder | 06/28/05
what next  charlescandy | 06/28/05
Who is breaking the law?  jfelton1@... | 06/28/05
Wrong is wrong  cococan | 06/28/05
Supreme Court rules against file-swapping firms  fetter | 06/28/05
I paid for it once, that's more than enough  sdwilliams2009 | 06/28/05
Man are you an a$$  lfagius | 06/28/05
Get over yourself  MrPcWizard | 06/30/05
Replacing already bought music  Bitsbuckets | 06/28/05
Yawwnnn! I don't share files anyway.  kiddpeat | 06/28/05
then find somewhere else to hang out  wise-eyes@... | 06/28/05
More than just a living  hankd74 | 06/28/05
Well said  ashraaq_wahab6789 | 06/28/05
Vicarious Liability Laws Have Much Precedent  Rick Morrow | 06/28/05
Here's a new and great Idea  hankd74 | 06/28/05
Ruling Unclear, Ambiguous & Unenforceable Internationally  grinnerwolf@... | 06/28/05
Goodbye Fair Use and the VCR ruling (NT)  Update victim | 06/28/05
Giants crush the people  racarr | 06/28/05
Copyright Music  BustaSize13inyoass | 06/29/05
Copyright Music  tellinitlikeitis | 06/29/05
file swappers 101  cadaholic | 06/29/05
Who are the truly bad guys?  fallguyx55@... | 06/29/05
File Swapping  benf_z | 06/29/05
this is bull@#$!  Harbour_z | 06/29/05
Supreme Court Wrong  matt65473 | 06/29/05
Files vs. guns  BlueKnight | 06/29/05
Bulls...  Bassman_z | 06/29/05
Bulls...  79spitfire | 06/29/05
RE: P2P Responsability  cmiller@... | 06/29/05
File sharing  cmneste@... | 06/29/05
How is this different from PO Boxes and mail fraud  mshelley | 06/29/05
P2P is not automatically an infringement.  WhiteSand | 06/29/05
Hypocritical!  len.prosper@... | 06/29/05
COMCAST is in real trouble  oliver_clozov | 06/29/05
Comcast is already paying the royalties for you.  bitbrush | 06/29/05
It dosent Surprise Me  mcreynolds2 | 06/29/05
Republicans, Democrates...follow the money!  bitbrush | 06/29/05
In fact  79spitfire | 06/29/05
File sharing has little to do with Party.  james4shari | 08/16/05
P2P Supreme Court decision  jbullis | 06/29/05
Yes, Stealing IS Still Ilegal  tbrutis1 | 06/29/05
Hogwash  ryan1952 | 06/29/05
P2P not Illegeal  Phaldon | 06/29/05
Outrageous  zdnetcharles | 06/29/05
Absolute B.S. (!!!)  semiautosyclone | 06/29/05
Grokster  scferg | 06/29/05
RIAA and MPA aren't going to stop it...  gworley@... | 06/29/05
Supreme Court rules against file-swapping firms  tellinitlikeitis | 06/29/05
Sadly, so many of you just need to grow up and  James Dean_z | 06/29/05
A suggestion to the record companies....  gworley@... | 06/29/05
Tell me  musicalmike | 06/29/05
P2P Legal or Not  donaldyu | 06/29/05
Should P2P companies be responsible for copyright Piracy?  roy.jasper@... | 06/29/05
P-to-P what's next?????????  lbhall40@... | 06/29/05
P-to-P what's next?????????  tellinitlikeitis | 07/02/05
The proverbial double-edged sword....  chinoarc1126 | 06/29/05
Victory for vendors?? NOT!!  julians@... | 06/29/05
where do you draw the line?  vwiswell | 06/29/05
I do not agree with the ruling  fzman | 06/29/05
This whole issue is flawed  maphisto | 06/29/05
file swapping  wcosales@... | 06/29/05
Doesn't matter if your friend will pay or not  maphisto | 06/30/05
So we can sue any facilitator of illegal activity?  arcteller | 06/29/05
File Swapping  aj_sandberg_jr | 06/29/05
Copying from radio  DickCaro | 06/29/05
Radio and TV?  glhadley_z | 06/29/05
Anyone who designs a system... Bucyruss  Malkavian_z | 06/29/05
File Swapping Firms  gbcurtis | 06/29/05
Insane  musicalmike | 06/29/05
I DO NOT Agree With The Supreme Court!!  timh111 | 06/29/05
Greedy music, movie companies  lozza05 | 06/29/05
Greedy music, movie companies  rsterrell3@... | 06/29/05
So...  musicalmike | 06/29/05
Putting intellectual property into proper perspective  larrylaw_45322@... | 06/29/05
Greedy music, movie companies  lozza05 | 06/29/05
Supreme Court rules against file-swapping firms  Jantoo1 | 06/29/05
File swapping is illegal  washedupangel | 06/29/05
So does this mean we can sue MacroShaft for lost time and productivity?  Rodsprague | 06/29/05
Let's sue Microsoft......  scotasys | 06/29/05
FINALLY !! It's about Time  aaronbaker | 06/29/05
Heres a question  musicalmike | 06/29/05
Your point would be valid if...  M.Fridholm | 06/30/05
FINALLY !! It's about Time  tellinitlikeitis | 07/03/05
What other "devices" should make companies liable?  Bassman_z | 06/29/05
Supreme Court rules against file-swapping firms  tellinitlikeitis | 06/29/05
Should P2P Companies be Responsible, etc.  rsterrell3@... | 06/29/05
It's all in the definitions...  amdm | 06/29/05
File sharing or porno for our children which?  james4shari | 06/29/05
Result of 50 year use of tape recorder??  GrosserGnu | 06/29/05
If its ilegal...  musicalmike | 06/29/05
Industry thinks it shouldnt have rec.  ingram091 | 06/30/05
P2P file swapping  hammer6924 | 06/29/05
Manufacturers of GUNS should be shut down if we use the same logic.  RainDrummer | 06/29/05
Or perhaps..  79spitfire | 06/29/05
P2P Ilegal  musicalmike | 06/29/05
Lets rise up  musicalmike | 06/29/05
We can now sue them the studios and such  creed21 | 06/29/05
Heres a thought  musicalmike | 06/29/05
Inconsistent "legal" thinking  Dageezer | 06/29/05
The Copyrite laws are wrong....  estarnes4@... | 06/29/05
Do Not Agree  jackjack5 | 06/29/05
Do Not Agree  topaz_z | 06/29/05
Who protects your right to your stuff?  yafecila | 06/30/05
your right (to an extent)  maphisto | 06/30/05
give them an inch they will take a mile  yafecila | 06/30/05
Sharing what I own  sryan@... | 06/30/05
I'm a bit confused here  yafecila | 06/30/05
why not  maphisto | 06/30/05
you didn't read the post I was referring to  yafecila | 06/30/05
I did read that post  maphisto | 06/30/05
Response  sryan@... | 07/01/05
Fay response, actually  yafecila | 07/03/05
Losing focus  TecDoc | 06/30/05
what about the CD burner manufacturers?  britbuddy | 06/30/05
ISPs & Newsgroup providers next ?  cardblower_z | 06/30/05
down the primrose path  skoony2@... | 06/30/05
law is law  konj | 06/30/05
and Extortion is still Extortion  OneTime | 06/30/05
broad contention  roncentral@... | 06/30/05
What's really Right?  Dr_Zinj | 06/30/05
Hmmm.....  MrPcWizard | 06/30/05
yard sale  maphisto | 06/30/05
How about This...  MrPcWizard | 06/30/05
RIAA = Pirates...here's proof.  Raymond Danner | 06/30/05
Aaron: If your studio is part of the MPAA....  Raymond Danner | 06/30/05
Industry loves technology until we use it  racintazz@... | 06/30/05
P2P and Ileagal downloading  youngones.fsnet.co.uk | 06/30/05
VERDICT NEEDS A FIX  alexalvaro | 06/30/05
Supreme Idiots  catco@... | 06/30/05
Supreme Stealing  catco@... | 06/30/05
Supreme Court case misrepresented  ingram091 | 06/30/05
sony will have to sue sony  motorhead_z | 07/01/05
P2P  ymitury | 07/01/05
Nonsense  SirKen | 07/01/05
P2P liability  peeseebeeb@... | 07/01/05
File swapping  Two4tejas | 07/01/05
Supreme Court's decision  RGS_one | 07/02/05
The Truth  artic316 | 07/03/05
My problem.  merchkins | 07/04/05
P2P will continue to fill in the blanks  Up2L8 | 07/05/05
Horse and Buggy  Freon | 07/09/05
The Purpose of Laws  DJnRF | 07/21/05
phoney home repairman  seegs | 11/12/05
phoney home repairman  seegs | 11/12/05

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement
advertisement

SmartPlanet

Click Here