Open-source divorce for Apple's Safari?

TalkBack 30 of 98:: Next »; « Previous

Thread View
Flat View

Not in this case: The divergence between Safari and the project is too large; not much can be returned.

You wrote:

The bright side of it
is that since KHTML is GPL and therefore Apple's forked tree must also be GPL, the KHTML folk are free to use anything good that comes out of Apple's tree and bring it into their own tree. So in that sense their ideals will be upheld.

But as the article notes:

As a result of that divergence, improvements made to Safari can't be easily contributed back to KHTML, leaving the open-source original at a disadvantage to its corporate-sponsored progeny.; Posted by: Anton Philidor Posted on: 05/12/05 You are currently: a Guest | Members login | Terms of Use

Reply to Story Reply to Message

Alert moderator to an offensive message

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

Just one question - Why? Roger Ramjet | 05/12/05

You are pretty much right. nucrash | 05/12/05

I'm quite sure you are wrong... BitTwiddler | 05/12/05

Not too hard to understand Fred Fredrickson | 05/12/05

Meeting the letter but not spirit... Anton Philidor | 05/12/05

Agreed rkadowns | 05/12/05

Such is the nature of freedom tic swayback | 05/12/05

RE: Such is the nature of freedom nightshade0143 | 05/12/05

Freedom to be nasty tic swayback | 05/13/05

What??? nomorems | 05/13/05

Feeling and Doing nomorems | 05/13/05

What lie exactly? tic swayback | 05/12/05

Lying Liars Roger Ramjet | 05/16/05

What does "join" mean? tic swayback | 05/16/05

The GPL encourages forking (in a good way) Michael Kelly | 05/12/05

Here, here! cashaww | 05/12/05

I checked and the license is actually LGPL DonnieBoy | 05/12/05

There are limits though Michael Kelly | 05/12/05

It really boils down as to wheather it is derived code or not. DonnieBoy | 05/12/05

Can you say "time to market"???? DonnieBoy | 05/12/05

You forget who you're dealing with tic swayback | 05/12/05

Wait a minute here... BitTwiddler | 05/12/05

Improved product? Joe Blow_z | 05/12/05

But is this simply a HE said SHE said thing? Laff | 05/12/05

Read the article Fred Fredrickson | 05/12/05

IF that is the case... BitTwiddler | 05/12/05

Exactly tic swayback | 05/12/05

Not pathetic, expected. Anton Philidor | 05/12/05

The bright side of it Michael Kelly | 05/12/05

Not in this case Anton Philidor | 05/12/05

But if Apple's improvements are that much better Michael Kelly | 05/12/05

It said, cashaww | 05/14/05

I was about to hammer you. rkadowns | 05/12/05

Expectations tic swayback | 05/12/05

RE: Exactly Iain_Peters | 05/12/05

Please show me where Apple broke the law tic swayback | 05/12/05

Meeting the letter of the law doesn't always result in a good public image. DonnieBoy | 05/12/05

Crybabies rkadowns | 05/12/05

Open Source = Communism = Failure...AGAIN rhinohat@... | 05/12/05

Another clueless response Tim Patterson | 05/12/05

FOSS isn't Leninism, yes. Anton Philidor | 05/12/05

Anyone cashaww | 05/14/05

No it's more like the traditional and VERY American Laff | 05/12/05

Then who owns the barn? Anton Philidor | 05/12/05

In the case of the Barn the trade off was the owners help Laff | 05/12/05

Great for barns... Anton Philidor | 05/12/05

In the end I tend to wonder if the whole Open Source and Linux Laff | 05/12/05

Disregarding patents and all other regulations... Anton Philidor | 05/12/05

I think the whole arguement about new drugs not being Laff | 05/12/05

Drug companies look for a peaceful life... Anton Philidor | 05/12/05

The problem with drug companies is that there is NO Laff | 05/12/05

And when you look for a match... Anton Philidor | 05/12/05

Gotta disagree Linux User 147560 | 05/12/05

I believe in kindness, too. Anton Philidor | 05/12/05

Unintended? rapson | 05/12/05

In the end the strongest survive Michael Kelly | 05/12/05

As I've been saying in my concerns about other area's Laff | 05/12/05

Maybe they consider killing commercial software companies as... Anton Philidor | 05/12/05

Maybe they consider killing commercial software companies as... Michael Kelly | 05/12/05

An open source company... Anton Philidor | 05/12/05

I don't see the failure in your example Michael Kelly | 05/12/05

Did you realize the strategy you describe... Anton Philidor | 05/12/05

RE: I don't see the failure in your example jacrav | 05/12/05

I did not realize dumping internationally was illegal Michael Kelly | 05/12/05

Yes, part of the anti-trust case... Anton Philidor | 05/12/05

First Linux User 147560 | 05/15/05

Good, thoughtful points. Anton Philidor | 05/16/05

By the way, sounds like you weren't a general. Anton Philidor | 05/16/05

A better comparison Johnny Mnemonic | 05/13/05

Nothing like using a tech article BitTwiddler | 05/12/05

I hate Apple, they are awful mlindl | 05/12/05

No worries Tim Patterson | 05/12/05

Cool Fred Fredrickson | 05/12/05

I don't own a browser that passes! dzash2000 | 05/12/05

Safari! Fred Fredrickson | 05/16/05

Dude! Stop jumping to conclusions here I'm a big fan Laff | 05/12/05

I get that all the time rapson | 05/12/05

Stereotyped...I'm not even a big music fan!?! Laff | 05/12/05

Slow day, eh? rapson | 05/12/05

Much ado about SOP dzash2000 | 05/12/05

RE: Much ado about SOP nightshade0143 | 05/12/05

This is one reason to use the GPL. Then they have to make it all public. DonnieBoy | 05/12/05

Apple declined to comment for this story. nikoli | 05/12/05

Yes typical and if one looks at Apple's long history Laff | 05/12/05

nikoli disses Apple once again... MacCanuck | 05/12/05

Not a big surprise ... George Mitchell | 05/12/05

If that's the case ? jacrav | 05/12/05

I agree ... George Mitchell | 05/12/05

I tend to doubt it....For one very good reason..Steve Jobs Laff | 05/12/05

Perspective Richard Flude | 05/12/05

the problem is the difference between what apple said and what they did. it wessonjoe | 05/13/05

What are you babbling about? tic swayback | 05/13/05

hey wait a minute, is anyone paying attention? doh123 | 05/12/05

just taking this authors word for it, and not looking at the code, i'd have wessonjoe | 05/13/05

Forget this author, let's ask an expert tic swayback | 05/13/05

Open Source World versus the Real World rhinohat@... | 05/13/05

Yeah...so what's the problem here? rottweilerus | 05/14/05

If Apple forked the KHTML codebase, they'd offer the code for download hipparchus2000 | 05/16/05

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Live Webcast: Activate Today! Realize ROI with Intel(r) vPro? Technology and LANDesk Intel Join the team from the Intel vPro Expert Center for an informative Webcast ... Download Now
Five Steps to Determine When to Virtualize YourServers VMware Server virtualization isn't just for big companies. Entry-level ... Download Now
VMware Infrastructure: A Guide to Bottom-Line Benefits VMware Frustrated by the costs of maintain ever larger data centers?or building ... Download Now

Premier Vendor Content Whitepapers, webcasts & resources from our Power Center Sponsors

Meet Doc

Here to help you with your Document Management Needs
Doc is an enigma. Born to a Russian ballerina and a German electrical engineer, he grew up in various locations in the United States. He’s seen the insides of more brands, versions, and generations of printer and printer-related hardware than almost anyone.
To learn more about this mysterious figure check out his blog on ZDNet and his Workspace on TechRepublic. You’ll be glad you did.
Produced by
ZDNet and

Read the original story

Open-source divorce for Apple's Safari?

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Premier Vendor Content Whitepapers, webcasts & resources from our Power Center Sponsors

Meet Doc

Blogs

Product Reviews

Videos

White Papers and Webcasts

Downloads

More

ZDNet News & Blogs

Product Reviews

Product Blogs

White Papers & Webcasts

Downloads