On CBS MoneyWatch: 5 Things You Should Buy at Walmart
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet
TalkBack 14 of 39:
Next »
« Previous
So let me get this straight...
Are you saying that HP didn?t do such a bad thing? Is the evidence you are using to support such a questionable stance is that there have been a few reporters in the past that have written fake stories, faked photos or participated in less then ethical practices? Are you saying we should just let the bad reporters off the hook and likewise we should not find HP?s conduct offensive either?

I do not follow you here. Reporters that have been caught faking anything in the news are practically drawn and quartered. And they do not just get to move to another desk in the newsroom afterwards either. They are summarily fired and typically never find a respectable job in the news business ever again. If what you are saying is that analogous treatment should be dished out for HP executives based on what happens to unethical reporters, letting HP off the hook would hardly be the result.

Maybe you are saying HP is just giving the news industry a little payback for the news business occasional breach of ethics by some reporters, so that makes HP?s behavior acceptable? I do not get how that would work?I mean I had really bad service a few months ago in a restaurant out of town, should I get a little ?payback? you think next time I go to my regular restaurant, even though their service is usually pretty good, and stiff the waitress there for her tip to get back at the other place? I just cant seem to make sense of your reasoning no matter how I look at it.

No matter how you cut it, HP behaved like corporate jackasses. Just because they cannot seem to keep their own confidential information confidential it does not give them the right to authorize invasive investigative techniques into peoples lives who do not even work for them.
Posted by: Cayble   Posted on: 09/21/06 You are currently: a Guest | Members login | Terms of Use

Alert moderator to an offensive message

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

And...  opensourcepro | 09/21/06
So what?  JackPastor | 09/21/06
No, but it would be nice to think  ebrke | 09/21/06
What Fiasco ?!  YukonRay | 09/21/06
Not a Fiasco?  adsanders@... | 09/21/06
Patriot Act  YukonRay | 09/22/06
Hurd's line in the sand  marileev@... | 09/21/06
Not exactly illegal, OR morally incorrect...  Scrat | 09/21/06
Which IP address ???  JackPastor | 09/24/06
HP has my vote  ITTech001 | 09/21/06
This issue is much bigger than HP  sandawana | 09/21/06
It will surprise you, but I generally agree  ITTech001 | 09/21/06
ZDNet needs you!  sandbagger | 09/21/06
So let me get this straight...  Cayble | 09/21/06
Why is HP's conduct any concern of yours?  YukonRay | 09/21/06
You have got to be kidding me?  Cayble | 11/12/06
Stand Up and Take a Stand!  YukonRay | 09/21/06
Difference between Celebrity vs. Business Journalism  MerBrans | 09/21/06
Uh-huh, riiigght  Lord Talon | 09/21/06
Journalism  ITTech001 | 09/21/06
This one doesn't bother me  John L. Ries | 09/21/06
Question about "pretext"  YukonRay | 09/21/06
Spelling  tawnyy | 09/21/06
It's illegal in California  John L. Ries | 09/21/06
Bait and Switch issue.  Cayble | 11/12/06
Assigning responsibility  PJMonaco@... | 09/21/06
Many ironies  outtanames999 | 09/21/06
Yellow Journalism  rkendsley | 09/21/06
Hurd has operational control of the compay  John L. Ries | 09/21/06
Are we really surprised...?  bayny | 09/21/06
Black and White Journalism  mighetto | 09/21/06
You missed the point.  YukonRay | 09/21/06
Yellow Journalism vs Advertisement vs Pay for Content  mighetto | 09/21/06
Finding a corporate thief is a good thing?  ladyirol | 09/21/06
Job of a CEO  JackPastor | 09/21/06
Data Harvesting!  ladyirol | 09/21/06
If Hurd knew about it - he should be fired!  numbersguy@... | 09/22/06
If Hurd knew about it - he should be fired!  numbersguy@... | 09/22/06
another email as evidence  schwana | 09/22/06

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

SmartPlanet

Click Here