On GameSpot: 54.2% of Xbox 360s fail - Report
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet
TalkBack 37 of 48:
Next »
« Previous
DMCRA, Are we lucky?
"Even some members of the subcommittee took a dim view of the proposal. "Theft is theft and property is property," said Rep. Butch Otter, R-Idaho"

Wow! So Rep. Butch Otter considers theft to be theft and property to be property.

Well Butch, try this idea. A program that allows a person to use a product that he/she legally purchased is a valuable property in its own right. A law that prevents the inventor of that program from selling it is theft of that person's right to recover the profit that he/she is due.

Jack Valenti and his cohorts do not want to protect their property. If they did then they would lock it up and keep it hidden. What they are trying to do is to control the property after they have sold it. In effect they are in violation of the "first sale" doctrine that has been upheld in many courts of this land. The DMCA violates this doctrine by prohibiting the purchaser of a product from treating the product in a manner that he/she desires.

Please note, Rep. Otter, that the prohibition in the copyright law which existed prior to the DMCA preventing the purchaser of the product from selling copies remains intact even with the full repeal of the DMCA. Repeal of this bad law will simply place the responsibility for protecting their copyrights back upon the copyright holders and require them to use the courts as intended, rather than allowing the courts to be bypassed.

The Digital Media Consumers' Rights Act should be a one sentence act. It should state: "The law known as the Digital Millennium Copyright Act is hereby repealed in total." You could optionally include a complete pardon for anyone who has been convicted under any provision of the DMCA.
Posted by: Update victim   Posted on: 05/13/04 You are currently: a Guest | Members login | Terms of Use
Reply to Story Reply to Message

Alert moderator to an offensive message

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

Does Valentii get it? The law already allows copies!  oldskool | 05/13/04
Exactly..  el1jones | 05/13/04
great post...  ryusen | 05/13/04
re: Does Valentii get it?  cbradshaw@... | 05/13/04
If I kick down my own door am I a burglar?  Nigel Johnstone | 05/13/04
I forgot the BIOS password on my 10,000 PC.. reset it.. lock me up!  Xunil_Sierutuf | 05/13/04
But it is illegal to break into your own car  voska | 05/13/04
Otter is a Republican  RobertoSalazar | 05/13/04
he's a politician...  ryusen | 05/13/04
An ex-politician's testimony  AbsolutelyNot | 05/13/04
Legalizes 'hacking'?  jdd48 | 05/13/04
Hey, Valenti- You were spot on with the VCR, too!  Xunil_Sierutuf | 05/13/04
AARRGGGG I'm falling!!  cybershoplifter | 05/13/04
Is this guy really this clueless ?  BitTwiddler | 05/13/04
He can't be  Chad_z | 05/13/04
He's a fat old failed luddite  Nigel Johnstone | 05/13/04
His last hurrah, so he doesn't care  AbsolutelyNot | 05/13/04
If only...  Tim Patterson | 05/13/04
What I'm about to do should make Jacks skin crawl  voska | 05/13/04
Cool, but don't forget  AbsolutelyNot | 05/13/04
What's realy being said.........  nite_w0lf | 05/13/04
Get some education first  voska | 05/13/04
I take it that you missed his demo to a congressional committee.  B.O.F.H. | 05/13/04
His Demo was useless  voska | 05/13/04
What DVD encryption actually does?  B.O.F.H. | 05/13/04
Read what jack Valenti has to say!  B.O.F.H. | 05/13/04
Read it, he's a crack pot alright  voska | 05/13/04
Absolutely right!  AbsolutelyNot | 05/13/04
i think you need to rephrease that...  ryusen | 05/13/04
Simple minds have simple thoughts.  Anton Philidor | 05/13/04
Don't talk about Stalin, Bitty will get your post deleted  Xunil_Sierutuf | 05/13/04
Speaking of "victims"  AbsolutelyNot | 05/13/04
Congressman Butch Otter  carlhomsher@... | 05/13/04
Make the DMCA a win for consumers!!  cybershoplifter | 05/13/04
Does a "Climate of Terror" help sales?  cybershoplifter | 05/13/04
These idiots think they're gods  skinbasket | 05/13/04
DMCRA, Are we lucky?  Update victim | 05/13/04
Hooray, I think?  CobraA1 | 05/13/04
Just in time, too, for some RIAA tricks o' the trade  AbsolutelyNot | 05/13/04
Sony 'Connect' a flop I think  Nigel Johnstone | 05/13/04
Sure can.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 05/13/04
Apples and oranges, Bits and Bytes  AbsolutelyNot | 05/13/04
Could be the reason for it  voska | 05/13/04
That's bullsh** line  voska | 05/13/04
blah blah blah PIRACY ROCKS!!!!!  cybershoplifter | 05/13/04
Nothing Like Panning For Attention  ParadigmOdyssey | 05/13/04
DMCA Does Not Explicitly Outlaw  ParadigmOdyssey | 05/13/04
It's all about money & power.  Zgeeman | 05/13/04

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement
Premier Vendor Content Whitepapers, webcasts & resources from our Power Center Sponsors
advertisement

IT Solutions for 2010

  • Get cost-effective strategies and roadmaps on the most important issues facing IT leaders in 2010! Learn how to easily cut costs and deliver greater efficiency starting with your database, IT compliance management and data center. Visit the IT Leaders Dashboard. Visit the IT Leaders Dashboard.
  • Read about top issues IT decision-makers face every day, plus get cost effective solutions to real life IT problems. Oracle Topline