On CBS.com: Watch Exclusive CSI Cross Over Video
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet
TalkBack 23 of 30:
Next »
« Previous
This time you left out the word
"Possibly." happy

it is about a bad patent that should never have been issued

The patent was wrongfully issued if it was not original, non-obvious, or the applicant never had an intention to reduce it to use. From what I read here, the challengers submitted evidence challenging the originality of the invention. Best I can tell, UC is bringing some earlier documents to verify the originality (the invention, not the filing date, would prevail). Curious though, there doesn't seem to be a challenge on the basis that UC did not implement - seems to me if they had the infringement would have been evident much sooner. Maybe this is something that is harder to prove.

While I agree the patent might be harmful, the question of whether it should never have been issued seems to be up in the air.
Posted by: IT_User   Posted on: 05/12/04 You are currently: a Guest | Members login | Terms of Use
Reply to Story No further replies to this post will be accepted.

Alert moderator to an offensive message

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

re: UC's comments  ryusen | 05/11/04
Agree !!! but  mabricen | 05/11/04
um...  ryusen | 05/11/04
Har!  FederalistPaperBoy | 05/11/04
I disagree ...  George Jay | 05/11/04
fortunately for us all...  eLurker | 05/11/04
You're assuming  IT_User | 05/11/04
thus, the word...  eLurker | 05/11/04
bank robbery?  ryusen | 05/11/04
Can't make exceptions for Microsoft.  systemcleaner | 05/11/04
and apple, and novell, and ibm, and...  eLurker | 05/12/04
never wanted to make an exception for MS...  ryusen | 05/12/04
disagree  richhayes | 05/12/04
Hard to call  IT_User | 05/11/04
True, but...  No_Ax_to_Grind | 05/11/04
my god...  ryusen | 05/11/04
Well...  zkiwi | 05/11/04
you are making a good argument...  eLurker | 05/11/04
Hafta disagree on one point  IT_User | 05/11/04
zkiwi  eLurker | 05/12/04
Whatever  zkiwi | 05/12/04
im getting the feeling  eLurker | 05/12/04
This time you left out the word  IT_User | 05/12/04
it_user  eLurker | 05/12/04
ends and means...  ryusen | 05/12/04
I really hate to do this again  IT_User | 05/12/04
???  eLurker | 05/14/04
In a sense, there is a rule  IT_User | 05/12/04
schools own patents?  V Sanders | 05/12/04
Good point!  IT_User | 05/12/04

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement
advertisement
Click Here

SmartPlanet

Click Here