On CNET: Tech gifts for every budget
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet
TalkBack 17 of 136:
Next »
« Previous
Stupid comment
DonnieBoy:

Your comment about MS being a communist model is borderline idiotic. To then add a rhetoric statement like "all discussions and news are closely controlled by those in power" is even more absurd. I seriously doubt that you have any clue of the differences and similarities between communism and capitalism. I would suggest to you to find some educational materials, starting with "the corporation" (a documentary film). You would VERY QUICKLY find that in this particular case, LINUX is much closer to the communist model (i.e. everyone owns everything, noone is given preference, noone is rewarded for doing better), and controlled news and public discussions are more in line with capitalism and corporatism (i.e. modern democracies). To also believe that MS does not want anyone to know the details of problems....duh. Neither does ANYONE ELSE. In what lala world do you live in? In the one where every company sends out a prospectus of their "bug fixes" and process problems to all their customers and stockholders, outlined in excrutiating detail? Or in the real world where you get a warm and fuzzy financial statement sent once a year by the Enron barons? This is true for every business in every sector and in every country. From the Mom-and-Pop corner stores all the way to the mega-corporations, NOONE will tell you their problems. The idea that Linux, apparently with a lot of magical pixie-dust, will have bugs fixed because they disclose them ("everyone sees the code, so everyone can fix it", right??) is apparently the smokescreen that many have predicted it would be. The sad fact is that at any one time only a handful of people are even looking at the code, a tiny fraction know what it means, and only one or two ever bother to make a difference. And all that out of the "goodness" of their hearts. Sounds a heck of a lot more communist than MS if you ask me.

If you can't intelligently comment on a particular situation, you should just keep "keeping on" instead of spreading nonsensical FUD on forums such as this.
Posted by: rock06r   Posted on: 05/06/06 You are currently: a Guest | Members login | Terms of Use

Alert moderator to an offensive message

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

Kinda knew this was coming...  Tony Agudo | 05/05/06
I've seen scattered anectodtal reports from users  toadlife | 05/05/06
That's understandable...  Tony Agudo | 05/06/06
minor issue  Linux Geek | 05/08/06
I thought...  rapson | 05/08/06
Yeah...hey!!  techboy_z | 05/08/06
Get Real Chum  Cayble | 05/08/06
I like the fact that this can not be swept under the rug.  DonnieBoy | 05/05/06
Message has been deleted.  toadlife | 05/05/06
Grow up  Necrolin | 05/05/06
Sorry  toadlife | 05/06/06
re: sorry  barsteward | 05/06/06
No problem with open source  toadlife | 05/06/06
The point is, if you had an argument, you would have made it.  DonnieBoy | 05/06/06
Usually, you can tell those that don't have an argument.  DonnieBoy | 05/06/06
Well, we never see Microsoft kernel developers freely speaking their mind  DonnieBoy | 05/06/06
Stupid comment  rock06r | 05/06/06
Linux is closer to the Libertarian model...  HypnoToad72 | 05/06/06
With Linux, all developers are free to speak their mind about the quality  DonnieBoy | 05/06/06
You need a brain  SouthernPride | 05/07/06
You need an argument. Go back and read my post and see what you find to  DonnieBoy | 05/07/06
Do you work for Microsoft  SouthernPride | 05/07/06
I don't work for crooks, so, no I don't work for Microsoft. Probably never  DonnieBoy | 05/07/06
I think you do  BFD | 05/08/06
Communism: Marx vs Reality  hulse_kevin | 05/08/06
Free to pursue self-interest  Anton Philidor | 05/08/06
power topic  tridell | 05/06/06
Precisely. Well said!  HypnoToad72 | 05/06/06
Propriatory model cannot sweep it under the rug either.  osreinstall | 05/06/06
Wow, all MS kernel developers are free to speak their mind? Nothing held  DonnieBoy | 05/07/06
I don't think so DonnieBoy  osreinstall | 05/07/06
Still, exactly like China, information and speach are closely controlled  DonnieBoy | 05/08/06
But the people that control it are free to discuss with each other.  osreinstall | 05/08/06
In China they have all kinds of internal discussions as well, but like MS  DonnieBoy | 05/08/06
DonnieBoy, you really are not thinking.  osreinstall | 05/08/06
Communist?  SouthernPride | 05/07/06
Well, in the sense that everything is free and open, and all are free to  DonnieBoy | 05/07/06
Really?  Real World | 05/08/06
The project is GPL, so Linus MUST keep everybody happy, or there will be a  DonnieBoy | 05/08/06
News flash  Real World | 05/08/06
News flash: revolutions are put down with force. Tiananmen Square??  DonnieBoy | 05/08/06
Hey I agree  Roger Ramjet | 05/08/06
America's Great  b.d.hi | 05/08/06
I like the fact that...  John Zern | 05/08/06
Well, the maintainer is concerned about bugs, but still an order of  DonnieBoy | 05/08/06
Yawn  Mark Miller | 05/09/06
Motivation  LordLiverpool | 05/06/06
It's a good thing  toadlife | 05/06/06
Here Here...  mdsmedia | 05/06/06
Eliminating bugs does not mean...  Anton Philidor | 05/08/06
confession -- more like transparency  tridell | 05/06/06
Bugs  The Tautologist | 05/06/06
How many bugs?  Spacely Spacerockets | 05/07/06
Oh no, there goes Redmond. Oh no, Bugzilla!  hulse_kevin | 05/08/06
It's a confession for the community, of sorts  Mark Miller | 05/09/06
Linux kernel 'getting buggier,' leader says  Loverock Davidson | 05/06/06
re: Linux kernel 'getting buggier,' leader says  barsteward | 05/06/06
What did I miss?  Loverock Davidson | 05/06/06
Actually...  John Le'Brecage | 05/06/06
and what you missed...  John Le'Brecage | 05/06/06
re: What did I miss  barsteward | 05/07/06
Not only that, but also...  zkiwi | 05/07/06
WARNING! WARNING!  lampdeveloper | 05/07/06
Proved my point perfectly  Loverock Davidson | 05/08/06
Just how is this any different than BSD?  Roger Ramjet | 05/08/06
Because its linux?  Loverock Davidson | 05/08/06
2 major differences, really...  Tony Agudo | 05/08/06
Patchy OS?  Kubuntoid | 05/10/06
Well once again the Linux  Linux User 147560 | 05/06/06
Perhaps  Loverock Davidson | 05/06/06
Hello...  Linux User 147560 | 05/06/06
I am so impressed  SouthernPride | 05/07/06
Doesn't take much to impress you though  Shelendrea | 05/08/06
You go girl happy  Hrothgar - PCLinuxOS User | 05/08/06
SuSE 9.1  Linux User 147560 | 05/06/06
Suse 9.1  SouthernPride | 05/07/06
SouthernPride you should  I'm Ye, the MS SHILL . | 05/08/06
Unbelievable  I'm Ye, the MS SHILL . | 05/08/06
It's ok  Shelendrea | 05/08/06
SP  Bite Me_Ax_Moron | 05/11/06
When you're right, you're right.  Anton Philidor | 05/08/06
Thank you Anton  Linux User 147560 | 05/08/06
bugs != features  linuxoverwindows | 05/06/06
Why does Morton care?  ye | 05/06/06
Gee Ye that's an easy one!  Linux User 147560 | 05/06/06
You are NOT a developer!  Spacely Spacerockets | 05/07/06
in a way, he's right, and you're being blind  Monkey_MCSE | 05/07/06
Who cares  SouthernPride | 05/07/06
if using common sense is considered  Monkey_MCSE | 05/08/06
Thank you for clarifying my intent...  Linux User 147560 | 05/07/06
That you are  SouthernPride | 05/07/06
Linux User's comments don't target process, but people.  bmonster | 05/08/06
you're right  Monkey_MCSE | 05/08/06
This was one of those times when I felt the need  Linux User 147560 | 05/08/06
I'm a developer !!!  I'm Ye, the MS SHILL . | 05/08/06
All good Jetson fans know ...  ShadeTree | 05/08/06
Gee did you get a lunchtime break  SouthernPride | 05/07/06
So tell me SP  Hrothgar - PCLinuxOS User | 05/08/06
Not according to the article.  ye | 05/07/06
More bugs? Or more users discovering old bugs?  Mr. Roboto | 05/06/06
They could do that...  Tony Agudo | 05/06/06
A better mechanism processing kernel is needed  eniak | 05/06/06
My rep and I have the power now...  Mike Cox | 05/06/06
I give it a...  Tony Agudo | 05/06/06
I have also  michael_t | 05/08/06
Mike, CFO has obtained control over your budget?  Anton Philidor | 05/08/06
Yet your rep can't give you a definitive Vista release date....  itanalyst | 05/08/06
You've been here a while...  John Zern | 05/08/06
Foolish Rush  Kimbok@... | 05/07/06
OS == politics :: OS == religion  Linux User 147560 | 05/07/06
Message has been deleted.  SouthernPride | 05/07/06
Gee, late night posting is bad...  Linux User 147560 | 05/08/06
Yeah, but you're still a target...  techboy_z | 05/08/06
ROFLMAO!  Linux User 147560 | 05/08/06
ROTFL  Shelendrea | 05/08/06
Traitor  Boot_Agnostic | 05/08/06
And Leon is getting LARRRRRGERRRR!!!!  itanalyst | 05/08/06
K, I'll bite...  Linux User 147560 | 05/08/06
Its a line from the movie Airplane.  widge_z | 05/08/06
Been a while...  Linux User 147560 | 05/08/06
Airplane Rocks! happy  Hrothgar - PCLinuxOS User | 05/08/06
Have a little patience people  Shelendrea | 05/08/06
Yes, indeed this is a huge issue!  michael_t | 05/08/06
More bugs or more bug reporters?  Exile_z | 05/08/06
Well at least there is BSD  netman4ttm | 05/08/06
Why oh why no fixed ABI for drivers?  stevey_d | 05/08/06
Honesty Rules  support@... | 05/08/06
The inmates are running the asylum?  computerworkspro | 05/08/06
I have been using a 2.6 kernel  Sysop1984 | 05/08/06
Torvalds considers "feature freeze" bug fix cycle  Tim Patterson | 05/09/06
The kernel may be fine but Fedora 5 feels buggier  Boot_Agnostic | 05/09/06
Pretty confident the kernel is good  Linux User 147560 | 05/09/06
I've just started to experiment with OpenSuSe 10  Boot_Agnostic | 05/09/06
maybe its fedora...  Sysop1984 | 05/09/06
most likely  Boot_Agnostic | 05/09/06
OSS not immune to traits of software development  Mark Miller | 05/09/06

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement
advertisement

SmartPlanet

Click Here