On mySimon: Holiday Gifts For The Hostess
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet
TalkBack 41 of 167:
Next »
« Previous
Ask Jim Greer - Supplemental No. 8: AutoZone claims are false
http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20040215015800694#c78161
Authored by: jbgreer on Wednesday, February 18 2004 @ 10:00 AM EST
QUOTE
don't know whether to be pleased or angry at SCO's assertion that IBM must have assisted AutoZone's transition to Linux due to the "precision and efficiency with which the migration occurred". You see, I was a Sr. Technical Advisor at AutoZone, where I was an employee for over 10 years. During my tenure, I participated and led in the design, development and maintenance of many of AutoZone's store systems. More importantly, I initiated AutoZone's transition to Linux and I directed the port of their existing store software base to Linux. I personally ported all of AutoZone's internal software libraries for use under Linux. I personally developed the rules by which other AutoZone developers should make changes to their code to support both Linux and SCO's OpenServer product. I believe at one point I had as many as 35 AutoZone developers performing porting work for me, much of which was trivial, given that our code did not generally rely on SCO specific features and that the more technologically sophisticated portions of our code tended to reside in our libraries. The developers were also responsible for testing their individual applications under both SCO and Linux; I supplemented this activity by performing builds of the entire AutoZone store software base on my desktop, which I had converted to Linux.

As to the claim that SCO's shared libraries were a necessary part of the port: false. No SCO libraries were involved in the porting activity.

As to the claim that IBM induced us to transition to Linux: false. It was, in fact, SCO's activities that 'greased the skids' and allowed the business case for using Linux to be made more easily. That is a story long in the telling; perhaps I'll share it another day.

One should remember the Linux business environment that existed at the time the AutoZone transition began. Several vendors - the original Caldera Linux distribution company, Red Hat, and Linuxcare - were offering support for enterprise installations of Linux. In fact, Bryan Sparks, then CEO of Caldera, flew to Memphis and met with me during my evaluation of the various distribution and support offerings. I also met and talked briefly with Dave Sifry of Linuxcare during the 1999 Linux Expo. AutoZone settled on Red Hat chiefly because of my familiarity with their distribution and the ease with which AutoZone could negotiate a support agreement with them.

I must add that SCO was eventually made aware of AutoZone's transition to Linux. They responded by offering to assist AutoZone in the porting activity. By the time of their offer, AutoZone had already completed the initial porting activity and had already installed a Linux-based version of their store system in several stores.

Finally, I'll add that I was for a time a member of SCO's Customer Advisory Board. As such, I believe I have some useful insights as to why SCO lost AutoZone's and several other large accounts' business.

Regards, Jim Greer
UNQUOTE
Posted by: David Mohring   Posted on: 03/03/04 You are currently: a Guest | Members login | Terms of Use

Alert moderator to an offensive message

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

They were forced to do it...  Mike Cox | 03/03/04
Get Real  regwells | 03/03/04
Please don't feed the Cox troll...  shawkins | 03/03/04
To be honest...  Hard Cider | 03/03/04
Sarcasm & humor  Some_one | 03/03/04
Regwells...  BitTwiddler | 03/03/04
Old Codger  regwells | 03/03/04
Talking about the rest of the world....  Northwolf | 03/03/04
Noooooooo!  Confused by religion | 03/03/04
Mr Troll, what about the law.  notbilln | 03/03/04
The joke is on you Cox....  Zen37 | 03/03/04
7.2 (NT)  Letophoro | 03/03/04
oh come on!  ryusen | 03/03/04
Feel free...  Letophoro | 03/03/04
7.8 (nt)  ryusen | 03/03/04
My kids Natsha and Xavier just don't get it  Squawkbox | 03/03/04
Tell Your Kids...  Letophoro | 03/03/04
There aren't ATMs in AutoZones, are there?  IT_User | 03/03/04
Yep, I get a kick out of his posts too.  Squawkbox | 03/03/04
Well then...  OleAndersen | 03/03/04
LOLOL  Hard Cider | 03/03/04
I'm rolling on the floor  sbourne@... | 03/03/04
Great to hear from Mike Cox  steve@... | 03/03/04
Is that your Microsoft Rep?  Mark Gist | 03/03/04
Mike my kids adore you  Squawkbox | 03/03/04
They were forced to do it lol  lotta_anger | 03/03/04
m$ pumping big $$ in sponsoring sco  stephen732@... | 03/03/04
(NT) BRAVO!  Solid Water | 03/03/04
Suing Daimler Chrysler might be a mistake  CobraA1 | 03/03/04
RE: Suing Daimler Chrysler might be a mistake  MG_z | 03/03/04
What an idiot  Bill Gates is Satan | 03/03/04
What an idiot  Bill Gates is Satan | 03/03/04
Glad you corrected that  Squawkbox | 03/03/04
If You Don't Pay You Don't Play  RobertoSalazar | 03/03/04
Want to buy a Quitclaim Deed to your house?  IT_User | 03/03/04
What is even more obvious...  Hamlet_z | 03/03/04
that's right  fmbma | 03/03/04
SCO is commiting corporate suicide!  George Mitchell | 03/03/04
Do they Hold and SCO Licence?  regwells | 03/03/04
If you are an SCO user, you might be at greater risk.  DonnieBoy | 03/03/04
Ask Jim Greer - Supplemental No. 8: AutoZone claims are false  David Mohring | 03/03/04
Sounds like AutoZone had their own source code...  Zogg | 03/03/04
Own programs.  Tim Patterson | 03/03/04
To the root ...  Vily Clay | 03/03/04
Unix the first OS?  Larry the Security Guy | 03/03/04
This is a shame.  vferrara | 03/03/04
also,  ryusen | 03/03/04
Autozone involvement with Linux predate IBM linux push  David Mohring | 03/03/04
SCO: ?I?ll rip off you because B.G. wants it.? Is it US Justice or MS? (NT)  Vily Clay | 03/03/04
System V copyrights????  Zogg | 03/03/04
I think they dropped that part of the lawsuit  el1jones | 03/03/04
My question is...  Zen37 | 03/03/04
You can sue ANYONE for ANYTHING  chrichton99 | 03/03/04
Yes, but....  Zen37 | 03/03/04
Best way to stop lawsuit abuse  mdowdey | 03/03/04
No better yet...  MkIIISupra | 03/03/04
This is being fed by microsoft "licensing" fees  maxo_z | 03/03/04
And Sun's, and SGI, and IBM, and...  No_Ax_to_Grind | 03/03/04
but  ryusen | 03/03/04
The idea is to intimidate  jfrankcarr | 03/03/04
Headline I would like to see  frgough@... | 03/03/04
I agree!!!  jbachandouris@... | 03/03/04
Time to take them to court  NemesisNL | 03/03/04
Just pay the fee and quit complaining about it  IT Consultant_z | 03/03/04
Why don't YOU PAY?  dochood | 03/03/04
Dear Dogbert  GrumpyOldMan | 03/03/04
or  pschroeder@... | 03/03/04
Aha!  Yen_z | 03/03/04
my favorite  pschroeder@... | 03/03/04
hey now!  ryusen | 03/03/04
Consultant  IT_User | 03/03/04
Close, but...  Yen_z | 03/04/04
hey slick...SCO is the one doing the complaining  isotla | 03/03/04
I'll sell you a Quitclaim Deed to your house  IT_User | 03/03/04
Mr. I/T ... You use software that is infringing on one of my copyrights  George Jay | 03/03/04
Paying BLACKMAIL reinforces the Blackmailer. (NT)  Update victim | 03/03/04
I vote with my wallet, and it says *NO*!  CobraA1 | 03/03/04
RE: Just pay the fee and quit complaining about it  MG_z | 03/03/04
And still no proof to back up their claims....  James T. Kirk | 03/03/04
Can anyone kill that spider?  FirstNLastN | 03/03/04
profit by litigation  david_b_mac | 03/03/04
Crash and Burn  bit_rot | 03/03/04
SCO forgot the law...  Joe in Minneapolis | 03/03/04
That's not the law  StorageGuru | 03/03/04
Mighty big presumption  IT_User | 03/03/04
You have to pay to play  StorageGuru | 03/03/04
still wiating  ryusen | 03/03/04
You say they will hear from SCO  IT_User | 03/03/04
Just keep getting dumber  NoB$ | 03/03/04
That is the law  openMind | 03/03/04
RE: That's not the law  MG_z | 03/03/04
Totally clueless  NoB$ | 03/03/04
It will be nice when...  Netizen Kane | 03/03/04
SCO is not sueing Autozone for the the same IP as IBM  sjworth@... | 03/03/04
Should be an easy defence  NTrant | 03/03/04
Even Easier Defense  msalomon | 03/03/04
Using a lawsuit to prime the pump  Bit Bucketteer | 03/04/04
3 issues  NT Admin | 03/03/04
The lack of infrastructure is showing here  StorageGuru | 03/03/04
Dont forget the defense fund at ODSL  Iain_Peters | 03/03/04
you're not bad...  ryusen | 03/03/04
Confusing post  IT_User | 03/03/04
It's pretty clear to me  StorageGuru | 03/03/04
If it's that clear  IT_User | 03/04/04
OK Chief  NT Admin | 03/04/04
OK Chief  NT Admin | 03/04/04
lol...someone boycotting Autozone  isotla | 03/03/04
Someone should hire Gates to rule the world  StorageGuru | 03/03/04
you have your MS opinion, I have mine...  isotla | 03/03/04
Certainly they benefit  StorageGuru | 03/03/04
hire gates to clean the stable  lotta_anger | 03/03/04
Only if he mnoves to Uranus first. (NT)  Update victim | 03/03/04
That's planet Uranus  Update victim | 03/03/04
Only if he moves to Uranus first. (NT)  Update victim | 03/03/04
That's planet Uranus. (NT)  Update victim | 03/03/04
stole what?  ryusen | 03/03/04
copied then  StorageGuru | 03/03/04
that statement is false to,  ryusen | 03/03/04
Have it your way for now  StorageGuru | 03/03/04
i'm starting to have trouble believing you're serious now...  ryusen | 03/04/04
HUH?  bgoss@... | 03/04/04
That's right  NoB$ | 03/03/04
StorageMan!!!!  nite_w0lf | 03/03/04
Not at all  StorageGuru | 03/03/04
It's bitty  NoB$ | 03/03/04
AKA Bill Weisgerber  IT_User | 03/04/04
STOMP!  Chad_z | 03/03/04
How tough is AutoZone?  StorageGuru | 03/03/04
You're still making a HUGE assumption  IT_User | 03/03/04
SCO has made a claim  StorageGuru | 03/03/04
Are you talking about the same SCO?  zd-spam | 03/03/04
Are you forgeting the 45 days in the IBM-SCO.......  nite_w0lf | 03/04/04
Please be a bit more discrete in your accusations  IT_User | 03/04/04
You don't show it  Bill Weisgerber | 03/04/04
re:  ryusen | 03/04/04
So you are "Storage man"?  IT_User | 03/04/04
Bull  regwells | 03/03/04
How can this be ???  BitTwiddler | 03/03/04
SCO is just a scratch off Lotto ticket  ejhonda | 03/03/04
AutoZone sales soar ...  mmorgan@... | 03/03/04
Criminal Charges against AZ, IBM, Linux, Novel  jfalknor | 03/03/04
Cute  NoB$ | 03/03/04
RE: Cute  jfalknor | 03/04/04
Re: SCO FILES SUIT AGAINST AUTOZONE  wadeprater | 03/03/04
It's not that simple  Jay_H | 03/03/04
Won't fly  NoB$ | 03/03/04
don't miss my point  Jay_H | 03/04/04
Until orig lawsuits are settled  FilledOut | 03/03/04
Doesn't matter if you win or lose...  Bit Bucketteer | 03/04/04
They won't have a leg to stand on against Daimler-Chrysler..  Northwolf | 03/03/04
that is irrelevant  Jay_H | 03/03/04
NOT since the DC headquarter is in Germany...  Northwolf | 03/03/04
So are you  NoB$ | 03/03/04
What is the date of the trial?  michael-t | 03/03/04
Has SCO yet provided specificity? (NT)  Update victim | 03/03/04
IT managers?  Jay_H | 03/03/04
Near as I can Figure  Squawkbox | 03/03/04
Im waiting for the grand finaly!  nite_w0lf | 03/04/04
SCO phone home !  pbva | 03/03/04
The DaimlerChrysler thing is a contract problem  Arrg | 03/03/04
This is too funny!  B.O.F.H. | 03/03/04
litigated America  john public | 03/03/04
Not likely  zd-spam | 03/03/04
this is court, not reality  Jay_H | 03/04/04
Criminal Complaints  jfalknor | 03/04/04
Just like the RIAA  Larry the Security Guy | 03/04/04
SCO jokes  mark70 | 03/04/04

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement
advertisement

Meet Doc