This needs to be appealed!
nite_w0lf | 02/23/04
|

Exactly..
Tim Patterson | 02/23/04
|
 
Come on folks, this is the California area again!
Spoon Jabber | 02/23/04
|
  
Schizophrenic?
Jose Jimenez | 02/23/04
|
   
No, Im just trying...
Spoon Jabber | 02/23/04
|
    
Yes we are!
Spoon Jabber | 02/23/04
|
     
NO! WE ARE NOT!
Spoon Jabber | 02/23/04
|
    
Protecting minorities
tic swayback | 02/23/04
|
     
WHAT?!?!
RAGE_z | 02/23/04
|
     
Excellent Post Rage! Tic you're off your rocker!
Spoon Jabber | 02/23/04
|
     
Scary responses from supporters of religious dictatorship
tic swayback | 02/24/04
|
     
Hey, Spoon Jabber
NoB$ | 02/24/04
|
     
Yo, spoonie jabber...
NoB$ | 02/24/04
|
     
Hey, complete B$
Spoon Jabber | 02/24/04
|
    
It is ridiculous
NoB$ | 02/24/04
|
     
YOU are rediculous!
Spoon Jabber | 02/24/04
|
  
??????
AbsolutelyNot | 02/23/04
|
   
There is a product...
Spoon Jabber | 02/23/04
|
  
Maybe had no choice
NoB$ | 02/24/04
|
   
What country are you in?
Spoon Jabber | 02/24/04
|
    
I'm in America, where are you? Iraq?
NoB$ | 02/24/04
|
     
See above, entitled "Hey, complete B$"
Spoon Jabber | 02/24/04
|
The Right to Backup
BSCpEUSF | 02/23/04
|

when I owner LPs
V Sanders | 02/23/04
|

You can't even do that!
Spoon Jabber | 02/23/04
|
 
Macrovision ruins the original after a while
AbsolutelyNot | 02/23/04
|
  
Yeah, tried that.
Spoon Jabber | 02/23/04
|
 
Defeating analog macrovision.
Jack-Booted EULA | 02/23/04
|

What Right
nucrash | 02/23/04
|

8-tracks
AbsolutelyNot | 02/23/04
|

I'm confused
Fred Fredrickson | 02/23/04
|
They can no longer deny we have the rite......
nite_w0lf | 02/23/04
|

They'd deny both if they could
Bobby Sskcat | 02/23/04
|

Your right, that is it
V Sanders | 02/23/04
|
Repeal the DMCA
Bobby Sskcat | 02/23/04
|

see my post below:
ryusen | 02/23/04
|
Maybe someone should sue the Movie Industry
el1jones | 02/23/04
|

Get Xcopy while you can !
NT Admin | 02/23/04
|

VCR
voska | 02/23/04
|
It doesn't break laws...
BitTwiddler | 02/23/04
|
There's a really easy fix if they were actually serious about this
Michael Kelly | 02/23/04
|

My Solution Exactly
bjornafreeman@... | 02/23/04
|
 
Replacements would cost next to nothing
voska | 02/23/04
|
Likely to have little effect
tero_t_vaananen@... | 02/23/04
|

Backups on DVD are illegal under this ruling.
Anton Philidor | 02/23/04
|
 
Backups are still legal
voska | 02/23/04
|
  
As long as they're made by non-digital means, yes.
Anton Philidor | 02/23/04
|
   
The difference is...
Fred Fredrickson | 02/23/04
|
 
I think one point is wrong
Spoon Jabber | 02/23/04
|
MPAA and RIAA are playing with fire
M_c | 02/23/04
|
We will get out backups from P2P (nt)
nite_w0lf | 02/23/04
|
WHY????
Unicornrider | 02/23/04
|

happens all the time
V Sanders | 02/23/04
|
I'm Ok with not being able to back-up my DVDs IF...
voska | 02/23/04
|
Of course she did...
Tim Patterson | 02/23/04
|

Sad, but true...
WhoIsDaMan | 02/23/04
|
Another Bought Judge
brenthawkinsmd | 02/23/04
|
Moronic!
KOS-MOS | 02/23/04
|
Only in Caifornia
dkwiatkowski@... | 02/23/04
|
DVD Backups
B_HI | 02/23/04
|
A Little Sanity Please
Louisiana oilman | 02/23/04
|

If the person paid for them...
BitTwiddler | 02/23/04
|
 
Point taken
Louisiana oilman | 02/23/04
|
  
What I want to do with what I bought
voska | 02/23/04
|

Library and Sports
AbsolutelyNot | 02/23/04
|

my views
voska | 02/23/04
|
Copying video/software is NOT a good thing
VideoGuy | 02/23/04
|

And NEVER back up your system before applying a patch. (NT)
Update victim | 02/23/04
|
 
Ahhh, Did you read anything at
VideoGuy | 02/24/04
|
we need technology aware judges...
ryusen | 02/23/04
|
In other news the record button was found to be illegal.
Arrg | 02/23/04
|
Just Went and bought DVD X Copy (Platinum)...
NeoGeek | 02/23/04
|
So is the software illegal or ppl have no right to backup, judge?
FilledOut | 02/23/04
|

Amended:
FilledOut | 02/23/04
|
DVD copying is illegal
TokyoPete | 02/23/04
|
Judge is dyslesic
ParadigmOdyssey | 02/23/04
|
(NT) http://www.clonedvd.net/ :o)
Jack-Booted EULA | 02/23/04
|
First sale ruling
Update victim | 02/23/04
|
This says it all......
James T. Kirk | 02/24/04
|

Actually that's fine by me
FilledOut | 02/26/04
|
Title 17
dacul | 03/04/04
|
Compromise
jriler@... | 08/26/04
|