Interesting Article!!
viruser | 07/05/07
|
Ah yes,
Roger Ramjet | 07/05/07
|

Stiction
big red one | 07/06/07
|
 
Stiction
pjrobertz@... | 07/06/07
|
  
Stiction also caused by stuck read/write heads
John Sawyer | 07/06/07
|
   
Stuck on stiction
Chiatzu | 07/06/07
|

Good ole days (?)
ed.segraves@... | 07/06/07
|
 
The good ol days..
Old Timer 8080 | 07/06/07
|
A quick off the on agian power
bjbrock | 07/05/07
|

Seconded.
HypnoToad72 | 07/05/07
|
 
Seagate
Bill4 | 07/05/07
|
  
No WD for me
big red one | 07/06/07
|
   
You Missed the Point
greybeardtechie | 07/06/07
|
    
THANK YOU
ivanotter | 07/06/07
|
     
SCSI
Northwolf | 07/07/07
|
     
emotional purchase
richvball44 | 07/07/07
|
   
WD is my problem as well...
Media-Ted@... | 07/06/07
|

But I wonder if anything will change
GuidingLight | 07/05/07
|
 
WEllll....
ivanotter | 07/07/07
|
Great article Robin!
D. T. Schmitz | 07/05/07
|
Avoid the Maxtor factor.
osreinstall | 07/05/07
|

I've had just the opposite experience.
Uber Dweeb | 07/05/07
|
 
I agree...
Scrat | 07/06/07
|
  
120MB WD
Sabz5150 | 07/06/07
|
 
Never even critized the WD.
osreinstall | 07/06/07
|

Anecdotal, anecdota, anecdotal
jawshoeaw@... | 07/06/07
|
 
The proof is a lot of returned Maxtors.
osreinstall | 07/06/07
|

Western Digital Drives are Best!
Brakiss | 07/06/07
|
 
Whatever guy.
osreinstall | 07/06/07
|
 
I like WD Caviars too
T1Oracle | 07/06/07
|

I agree Maxtor drives are nothing but trouble.
docbillnet | 07/06/07
|
 
Your concerns about them being all bad in the future is just worry.
osreinstall | 07/06/07
|
 
I've had the opposite experience with Maxtor
intrepi@... | 07/06/07
|
  
Same here intrepid
a155mm | 07/06/07
|

quality power supply
gkrwc | 07/06/07
|
 
Yes, a quality power supply.
osreinstall | 07/06/07
|
Brand preference
itpro_z | 07/06/07
|

I almost agree with you.
bjbrock | 07/06/07
|

Two types of user
tony@... | 07/06/07
|
 
Im both!
amatbrewer@... | 07/06/07
|

Finally someone who gets the article
longzoo | 07/06/07
|

Interesting. I never lost SCSI drives, even second-hand ones
labarker | 07/06/07
|
Disk Drive Life...
mrlinux | 07/06/07
|

Disk Drive Life...
rkeel | 07/07/07
|
 
someone who REALLY gets it
richvball44 | 07/07/07
|
Seagate and Western Digital FTW
support@... | 07/06/07
|

My recent experience is opposite; RAID Beware
tony@... | 07/06/07
|
 
Yeah whatever.
codeguy007 | 07/07/07
|
Drive reliability
dancac | 07/06/07
|

Spinrite
Raymond Danner | 07/08/07
|
ala John Bender...
srobtjones@... | 07/06/07
|
Maxtor Drives
reloader3@... | 07/06/07
|

Mantor?
John Sawyer | 07/06/07
|
Maxtor Drives
reloader3@... | 07/06/07
|

Age, not brand
Borg_Tribble | 07/06/07
|
The moral is - cover your butt
josephmartins | 07/06/07
|

Reiterate what Robin is saying
sphillips@... | 07/06/07
|
Totally unexpected reasons for drive failures
alajon | 07/06/07
|
HD Smackdown
handyman315 | 07/06/07
|
Power factor
abrtal@... | 07/06/07
|
You posed the question ...
hchelette@... | 07/06/07
|
failure mode
carl@... | 07/06/07
|
Drives depend on care not luck
jurgislasevicius@... | 07/06/07
|

Spring/Fall failures
alajon | 07/06/07
|

Basic rules for BUILDERS.
Old Timer 8080 | 07/06/07
|
Fujitsu and other f-words
ccompton@... | 07/06/07
|
It depends on Murphy' Law
desert916@... | 07/06/07
|
Agreed!
sam@... | 07/06/07
|
Disk drive life
petrasys@... | 07/06/07
|
backups
cwallen19803 | 07/06/07
|

My backup plan, my 2-cents' worth
Reality-based | 07/06/07
|
 
Backup method
sphillips@... | 07/06/07
|
  
Cloning Drives
james-38@... | 07/06/07
|
  
haha
richvball44 | 07/07/07
|
 
Nova Backup
ViperHost | 07/06/07
|
Yes on M
lourayr | 07/06/07
|

what it tells me
sailnavy | 07/06/07
|
 
Dell
gapinsky | 07/06/07
|
 
Re: Ms
lourayr | 07/06/07
|
Hard Drive Life for laptops
gapinsky | 07/06/07
|
How About a Survey re: Brand?
Your Mom 2.0 | 07/06/07
|
Re: Ms
lourayr | 07/06/07
|
Disk Life
whainswo@... | 07/06/07
|
We are all missing the point
sphillips@... | 07/06/07
|
My offspring, who once built PCs for a living...
Feldwebel Wolfenstool | 07/06/07
|

CIGARETTE SMOKE is the KILLER....
Feldwebel Wolfenstool | 07/09/07
|
 
say what?
The_Quietman | 07/11/07
|
  
The tar and other chemicals can still reak havoc
D-cat | 07/11/07
|
Drive Life
mb96001@... | 07/06/07
|
There are only two types of hard drives:
mbarker@... | 07/06/07
|
Avoid Maxtor. However there is no drive that last forever.
phatkat | 07/06/07
|
How about dust?
jpatten | 07/06/07
|
I do not agree it is all "Luck"...
XweAponX | 07/06/07
|

Leave ON, use SMART, avoid heat and shock
warreno@... | 07/06/07
|
RAID 5
bhalper | 07/06/07
|
missing the point (most)
desamuelson | 07/06/07
|
Maxtor diamondmax sata 2 drives -my choice
intrepi@... | 07/06/07
|

Customer Service
codeguy007 | 07/07/07
|
Use an external drive for back-up
mflemming@... | 07/06/07
|

Regarding Externals...
XweAponX | 07/06/07
|
Usually..
firehound | 07/06/07
|
This is not good science
ProfessorJim | 07/06/07
|

Theory vs experiment
R Harris | 07/06/07
|

You talk of real world usage...
Cayble | 07/06/07
|
 
Good point: I have no data on retail packaging
R Harris | 07/08/07
|

Why avoid OEM?
notsofast | 07/10/07
|
 
Exactly!
Cayble | 07/15/07
|
sata, chair mats, ammonia problems
hlee_z | 07/06/07
|
THANK YOU
ivanotter | 07/06/07
|
Testing ICs VS Testing Drives
Old Timer 8080 | 07/06/07
|
Sampling theory
Ken_Hope | 07/06/07
|

Sampling size
desamuelson | 07/06/07
|
Hard Drives Designed to Fail over time?
reqadr@... | 07/06/07
|

Magnetic coercivity is *much* higher than it
R Harris | 07/08/07
|
And Grounds for a Lawsuit
mejohnsn | 07/06/07
|
I've never had a drive fail
Leria | 07/06/07
|
power is a big situation with
lokeusa2007@... | 07/06/07
|
Few drive failures over the years
rdhalsteatzd | 07/06/07
|
More than one way to loose datat the a hardware failure.
Baaama@... | 07/06/07
|
More than one way to loose data on a HD than hardware failure.
Baaama@... | 07/06/07
|

Guess you never heard of...
tek_heretik | 07/06/07
|
The only failure I have ever saw was...
tek_heretik | 07/06/07
|
Questions
Chiatzu | 07/06/07
|

Neither study looked at notebook drives
R Harris | 07/08/07
|
Hmmm
Linux User 147560 | 07/06/07
|

Drive use.
D-cat | 07/10/07
|
Mounting position can make a difference
davidpl | 07/06/07
|
Cooling does count with Maxtor
a155mm | 07/06/07
|
ST1144A, 20megs.. forget how old
lpiatt@... | 07/06/07
|
Just lost one last week
ivanotter | 07/07/07
|
IS THERE ANYTHING YOU CAN DO? YES.
ragnar.moller@... | 07/07/07
|

RAID 5 not nearly as safe as you'd think
R Harris | 07/08/07
|
Disc Drives
waddykins | 07/07/07
|
Disk Drive Life
rkeel | 07/07/07
|
They are all pretty reliable
bobsherrill@... | 07/07/07
|

True, until they fail.
R Harris | 07/08/07
|
Only two kinds of drives
ron_d_harris@... | 07/07/07
|
My drive experiences
sborsher | 07/08/07
|
Wow! Boiling rice!
jsargent | 07/09/07
|
Smartest thing for home users to do
Dr_Zinj | 07/09/07
|

Suggest external
D-cat | 07/10/07
|
Disk drives are like cars...
pyropakjim@... | 07/09/07
|

Repairs
D-cat | 07/10/07
|
Try SCSI
shepta@... | 07/09/07
|
What about MTBF
THEE WOLF | 07/10/07
|

Already Answered
D-cat | 07/11/07
|
 
Need the testing parameters
desamuelson | 07/16/07
|
What about vibration/bouncing?
danls@... | 07/19/07
|
more factors
kevencage | 07/19/07
|
Interesting stuff
Ivan_the_stinky | 08/09/07
|
What about power down/power up?
cmwiswall | 08/25/07
|