probably wouldn't have happened but....
JoeMama_z | 08/23/06
|

AAC or Fairplay?
tic swayback | 08/24/06
|
 
damn right!
JoeMama_z | 08/24/06
|
Apple...
bgonetoo | 08/23/06
|

Awwww, does big bad Apple scare widdle bgonetoo?
BitTwiddler | 08/24/06
|

Did they really get a black eye?
dave95. | 08/24/06
|
 
They are not "going after" other companies
John Zern | 08/24/06
|
  
Not the whole interface
tic swayback | 08/24/06
|
Where is everyone?
mdemuth | 08/23/06
|

Here I am
Len Rooney | 08/24/06
|
 
No winners, No losers......
linux for me | 08/24/06
|
  
Well
Len Rooney | 08/24/06
|
   
How would that get Apple any money?(nt)
ShadeTree | 08/24/06
|
    
It's part of the settlement
dave95. | 08/24/06
|

No they won't
Boot_Agnostic | 08/24/06
|

Less than thrilled with this settlement
tic swayback | 08/24/06
|
 
Every company says they settled ...
ShadeTree | 08/24/06
|
  
Do you think this is a good patent?
tic swayback | 08/24/06
|
   
Whether you agree or disagree ....
ShadeTree | 08/24/06
|
    
Expensive is the key
tic swayback | 08/24/06
|
    
Depends on "IF" and I did say "IF" Creative could count
Laff | 08/24/06
|
    
Maybe they felt it would put their scrollwheel patent
Boot_Agnostic | 08/24/06
|
  
Legal Fees
Patrick Jones | 08/24/06
|

Just because Apple Paid, doesn't mean Creative is right...
BitTwiddler | 08/24/06
|
 
Doesn't make Creative ...
ShadeTree | 08/24/06
|
  
Apple's counter suit?
dave95. | 08/24/06
|
   
Interesting spin but ...
ShadeTree | 08/24/06
|
    
Ummm....I would call this a tie...
nomorems | 08/24/06
|
     
Of course you would!
ShadeTree | 08/24/06
|
  
because
doh123 | 08/24/06
|
   
Grow up.
ShadeTree | 08/24/06
|
    
Nor no end to what Microsoft fans will say to disparge anything not MS (NT)
nomorems | 08/24/06
|
     
How was that disparaging to Apple?
ShadeTree | 08/24/06
|
  
No precedent since it was never tried. It was settled. (NT)
nomorems | 08/24/06
|
   
There absolutely was a precedent set.
ShadeTree | 08/24/06
|
    
Not a legal precendent so no worries (NT)
nomorems | 08/25/06
|
I missed/missing something
LibrarianDude | 08/23/06
|

patent for a hierarchical tree view of info? M$ and Unix should have shot
wessonjoe | 08/24/06
|

Yes, i agree.. this patent stuff, especially over stuff like this, stupid
Been_Done_Before | 08/24/06
|
MacCentrics.........
bgonetoo | 08/23/06
|

Well I guess I'm a MacCentric though I prefer fantic if you please:)
Laff | 08/24/06
|
 
The $100 million is just the settlement.
ShadeTree | 08/24/06
|
  
I don't think so
tic swayback | 08/24/06
|
   
It also allow Creative to put made for ...
ShadeTree | 08/24/06
|
    
Hehehe
dave95. | 08/24/06
|
     
How many accessories?
John Zern | 08/24/06
|
    
That translates into more profits for Apple
tic swayback | 08/24/06
|
     
If you belive people buy iPODs because ...
ShadeTree | 08/24/06
|
     
I may not know alot about marketing but before one
Laff | 08/24/06
|
     
Business lesson
tic swayback | 08/24/06
|
     
Go back to school!
ShadeTree | 08/24/06
|
     
Can't agree Shade
tic swayback | 08/24/06
|
     
Tic, your still wrong!!!
ShadeTree | 08/24/06
|
     
My point exactly
tic swayback | 08/24/06
|
     
People don't buy the iPod for accessories...
nomorems | 08/24/06
|
     
I bought one for the accessories
tic swayback | 08/25/06
|
  
Wrong
MacGeek2121 | 08/28/06
|
I'm gonna patent breathing!
Reverend MacFellow | 08/24/06
|

It must be crushing ...
ShadeTree | 08/24/06
|
 
That was lame
Rick_K | 08/24/06
|
  
actually, US law is who created first....
doh123 | 08/24/06
|
   
Then why?
Rick_K | 08/25/06
|
    
Patent Review Process
tic swayback | 08/25/06
|
     
Sounds about right...
Rick_K | 08/25/06
|
 
Was this specific part of the iPod/iTunes combo considered
Laff | 08/24/06
|
Patent system is Broken
dwjunix | 08/24/06
|
Better news for Apple
tic swayback | 08/24/06
|

DELL = Uncool
dave95. | 08/24/06
|

And that is germane in what way?
No_Ax_to_Grind | 08/24/06
|
 
Same market, competition is failing
tic swayback | 08/24/06
|
 
I think it's Dutche or Frenche
nomorems | 08/25/06
|

I miss my Dell DJ Gen 1
Boot_Agnostic | 08/24/06
|
 
Ironic that something called an iRiver would have problems
Laff | 08/24/06
|
  
Beauty in the eye of the beholder
Boot_Agnostic | 08/24/06
|
   
Yeah I got a clear protective case for my Black Video iPod.
Laff | 08/24/06
|
    
Hey! My 1st generation iPod is still kicking!
nomorems | 08/24/06
|
     
That last part was a bit disparaging
Boot_Agnostic | 08/25/06
|
Creative's Apple settlement no help to Nomad listeners
briagar | 08/24/06
|
I don't get it..
nomorems | 08/24/06
|

Kudos for Apple for not fighting the case out to the end
MacGeek2121 | 08/28/06
|
Cell phones and not patents will be the iPod killer.
ShadeTree | 08/24/06
|

I agree here
tic swayback | 08/24/06
|
 
Apple can't break into the cell phone ...
ShadeTree | 08/24/06
|
  
That's what's going to be interesting here
tic swayback | 08/24/06
|
   
The only problem with an unlocked phone...
nix_hed | 08/29/06
|

I don't know...
Rick_K | 08/25/06
|