On mySimon: Clip On Golf Bag Pocket Watch
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet
TalkBack 15 of 95:
Next »
« Previous
Are you then in favor of anarchy?
Like it or not, power does have to be granted, even though some will abuse it. I'm not suggesting that people be jailed without evidence, only that it is the business of the police not only to investigate crimes that have already happened, but also planned criminal activity.

In the case of the subject at hand, we're talking about publicly available information. Anyone with the know how and resources can do what the CIA is proposing to do (it's even legal)... even terrorists and other criminals as an aid to their activities; so why should government types be prohibited from doing so as well?

I'm not arguing that this program is a good use of government funds. As stated by others, real terrorists aren't likely to use chat rooms for anything but propaganda and recruitment. There is, however, nothing wrong with government types using publicly available information to carry out their legitimate functions. It certainly doesn't constitute a general search.
Posted by: John L. Ries   Posted on: 11/26/04 You are currently: a Guest | Members login | Terms of Use
Reply to Story No further replies to this post will be accepted.

Alert moderator to an offensive message

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

As though real terrorists would use chat rooms  Jeff Spicoli | 11/24/04
I have to agree with Jeff's basic point.  Laff | 11/24/04
And hey...  Jeff Spicoli | 11/24/04
4th Amendment  John L. Ries | 11/24/04
Ya know..I have NEVER given a blank about legal/Illegal  Laff | 11/24/04
Exactly  Jeff Spicoli | 11/24/04
I dunno, Jeff.  Judas I. | 11/24/04
Well at the very least I do enjoy the thought of being  Laff | 11/26/04
yea and nay  linuxoverwindows | 11/25/04
I agree, but...  John L. Ries | 11/24/04
Furthermore...  John L. Ries | 11/24/04
the okc bomber?  linuxoverwindows | 11/25/04
Look here  Jeff Spicoli | 11/25/04
Give ANY power to a person/goverment it will be ABUSED  Laff | 11/26/04
Are you then in favor of anarchy?  John L. Ries | 11/26/04
No NOT anarcy..but a VERY limited government where  Laff | 11/29/04
Remember the old adage...  eulagree | 11/29/04
theyre watching you right now  linuxoverwindows | 11/25/04
George Carlin said it best  AbsolutelyNot | 11/26/04
delorean  linuxoverwindows | 11/25/04
ASSUMED innocent until PROVEN guilty....that has some  Laff | 11/29/04
You Know What Live Spelled Backward Is?  eulagree | 11/29/04
You're right and you're wrong  seosamh_z | 11/24/04
What about foreign chatrooms?  j.m.galvin | 11/24/04
Precisely why real terrorists would NEVER use it  Jeff Spicoli | 11/24/04
They Use Any Means Necessary  nikoli | 11/24/04
You are assuming a level if intelligence that to my  Laff | 11/26/04
heres an idea...  linuxoverwindows | 11/25/04
Hey...  Jeff Spicoli | 11/25/04
Wrong!  WhoIsDaMan | 11/24/04
Agreed  John L. Ries | 11/24/04
What's an illegal combatant?  voska | 11/25/04
You mean it's SUPPOSED to apply...  BitTwiddler | 11/26/04
Supposed to Apply  Inventor_z | 11/29/04
Cell phones  John L. Ries | 11/24/04
chat, email, internet oh, my!  linuxoverwindows | 11/25/04
Haven't Cought on Yet??  Inventor_z | 11/29/04
Ya know I use to work in a small dairy in Maine...  Laff | 11/29/04
But...  AbsolutelyNot | 11/26/04
And that is the POINT...Not to catch terrorists, but  Laff | 11/26/04
But  Inventor_z | 11/29/04
That's even if...  eulagree | 11/29/04
Half the point  Roger Ramjet | 11/29/04
Even the paranoid have enemies...heh heh heh  Laff | 11/29/04
Hmm, Hard one.  Roger Ramjet | 11/29/04
Never said that one could prove that there is NO God.  Laff | 11/29/04
Another adage...  eulagree | 11/29/04
We have our ways....  No_Ax_to_Grind | 11/24/04
Good thing I keep those to a MINIMUM!  Laff | 11/24/04
memory  linuxoverwindows | 11/25/04
Love the use of "we"  AbsolutelyNot | 11/26/04
Why would terrorists go into a chat room?  coffeenite | 11/24/04
Tradecraft  quietLee | 11/24/04
And they call JEFF ...  Judas I. | 11/24/04
Sorry  quietLee | 11/24/04
LOL!!! That's hilarious!!  itanalyst | 11/24/04
Dang! Thanx, itananlyst, ...  Judas I. | 11/24/04
funny thing is...  linuxoverwindows | 11/25/04
The American Tyranny Won't Last Much Longer Anyway  itanalyst | 11/24/04
America is going to completely collapse within 10-20 years  Jeff Spicoli | 11/24/04
You are WELCOME.....:)  Laff | 11/24/04
Are you taking requests?  Yen_z | 11/24/04
No problem.....However I've felt for years that there  Laff | 11/26/04
I can help!  Yen_z | 11/26/04
I am a FALSE God, but in this I stand in some very  Laff | 11/29/04
Chat Rooms Are A Waste, They Are Looking In The Wrong Place  itanalyst | 11/24/04
I generally agree...  John L. Ries | 11/24/04
Not so sure  AbsolutelyNot | 11/26/04
theyre not actually...  linuxoverwindows | 11/25/04
Why limit the options?  Martin Marvinski | 11/28/04
The Thought Police  dem_z | 11/24/04
I try NOT to think..gets in the way of ACTION!  Laff | 11/24/04
speaking of action...  linuxoverwindows | 11/25/04
I'm pretty sure that this government is no longer  Laff | 11/26/04
War on Terror.  rhammock | 11/24/04
prohibition  linuxoverwindows | 11/25/04
prohibition would never happen in our time  JasonL31 | 11/26/04
would, or do? :P  linuxoverwindows | 11/27/04
what don't they spy  M_c | 11/24/04
Jurisdiction?  mobrien_12@... | 11/24/04
I don't like this.  KOS-MOS | 11/24/04
That's the whole point  Jeff Spicoli | 11/24/04
the government had information on the last attack  JasonL31 | 11/25/04
as the terrorist adapt  JasonL31 | 11/25/04
yeah, washington dc.  linuxoverwindows | 11/27/04
While they are  michael-t | 11/27/04
What a joke!  Robertbrice | 11/28/04
Some explanation... ?  Martin Marvinski | 11/28/04
Why should anyone bother showing you proof???  Jeff Spicoli | 11/28/04
Ok here is the reasoning  Robertbrice | 11/28/04
After 9/11 I became less free..not because the  Laff | 11/29/04
Security officials to spy on chat rooms  Inventor_z | 11/29/04
Good advice, but never been my style.  Laff | 11/29/04
Am ALREADY unlucky, Inventor.  Judas I. | 11/29/04
Terrorists using Chat Rooms?  eulagree | 11/29/04

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement
advertisement
  • Smart Tech Expert advice on innovations in healthcare and the green technologies that make it happen. Find out more
  • Smart Business Discussion and advice on management issues that revolve around making your world smarter and more useful. More Smart Advice
  • Smart People The best and worst moves in the management and strategy trenches. Learn More