On mySimon: Backpacker Magazine Award Winners
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet
TalkBack 45 of 53:
Next »
« Previous
DVD John and Airport
There are two issues to consider about DVD Jon's latest moves.

1. DVD John's work around of AirPort is important, because it shows that encrypted commercial systems for entertainment are not ready for prime time. If a business is going to base its revenue stream on encrypted sales of entertainment media, and that entertainment media can be compromised so early by an idealistic hacker, then it is not a good risk for those wishing to build a long-term profit base business model.

2. Some business people seem to think that if DVD John is prosecuted then this will greatly lower the odds of others doing this. I do not think this is so, because, if their history of behavior is any indication, idealistic hackers who show the limits of encryption systems will simply work behind the scenes to undermine such commercial encryption. It's better to know who DVD John is (and others like him) so that their talents can stand as "open source" hacking. This would allow industry to continually shore-up the holes in various encryption systems. Something like this is happening for the Windows operating system, and whether done for love or hate, it at least forces fixes to be launched regularly by Microsoft. Give such hacks glory, hire them if you want to, but don't throw the in jail or fine them. They may be irritants, but at least they are indeed irritants in our favor.
Posted by: brinticus   Posted on: 08/13/04 You are currently: a Guest | Members login | Terms of Use

Alert moderator to an offensive message

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

(NT) What a ********  James T. Kirk | 08/13/04
Message has been deleted.  James T. Kirk | 08/13/04
But John you have just done what the hacker did  Squawkbox | 08/13/04
Logic  seosamh_z | 08/13/04
He is not helping things any  James T. Kirk | 08/13/04
Bzzzztttt! Wrong Answer  GMTobias | 08/13/04
OK  James T. Kirk | 08/13/04
I don't see a problem with this  voska | 08/13/04
Not quite right  rapson | 08/13/04
Actually  GMTobias | 08/13/04
not quite wrong...  rafe01 | 08/14/04
dongles fialed in the past  V Sanders | 08/14/04
the day i lost fair rights usage.....  paul_bruford@... | 05/25/09
Cool  FilledOut | 08/13/04
HE likes doing this  crocd | 08/13/04
Because he can....  Patrick Jones | 08/13/04
Does Apple have patents on this?  crocd | 08/13/04
Good Question  Patrick Jones | 08/13/04
Patents don't protect you from hacking.  gordon@... | 08/13/04
DVD Jon is in for a BIG surprise...  realitycheck101 | 08/13/04
The laws have changed in Norway?  Michael Kelly | 08/13/04
Sorry  seosamh_z | 08/13/04
Norway Prisons Are NICE . . . : )  xero11 | 08/13/04
A question of cultural attitudes  Bill_gates_Is_SATAN | 08/13/04
Didn't Say He Would Do Time . . .  xero11 | 08/13/04
Personallys I'd prefer a Socialist prison over capitolist  voska | 08/13/04
I Got It  xero11 | 08/13/04
Poor MS  nomorems | 08/13/04
No, I said different.  seosamh_z | 08/13/04
No Convicts On This Board  xero11 | 08/13/04
Poking fun  seosamh_z | 08/13/04
no prison is nice...  rafe01 | 08/14/04
whaaaa!  paul_bruford@... | 05/25/09
I bet you are in for more of a surprise  Squawkbox | 08/13/04
"Revealed public key"?  FirstNLastN | 08/13/04
"bypassed DeCSS encryption schemes"???  FirstNLastN | 08/13/04
Hacking the protocol vs. implementing a new one  Michael Kelly | 08/13/04
Why I still use cassetes versus an IPOD  Squawkbox | 08/13/04
Wunderbar fantastisch!  nomorems | 08/13/04
Ich danke Ihnen vielmals  Squawkbox | 08/13/04
Like using a BMW to haul trash...  kd5auq | 08/13/04
Huh?  xero11 | 08/13/04
of course it can  rafe01 | 08/14/04
Our HERO!!  Xunil_Sierutuf | 08/13/04
DVD John and Airport  brinticus | 08/13/04
I don't see anything wrong  WhoMe_z | 08/13/04
That's it, take Apple down a peg, they hate it  FilledOut | 08/13/04
More Sales.....  middle of nowhere | 08/13/04
No Thanks  zeusfuse | 08/14/04
I am not sure this is helpful ...  George Mitchell | 08/14/04
how do you infer a crime here?  V Sanders | 08/14/04
Novel legal theory...  John Le'Brecage | 08/14/04
Regarding comments from...  msdead | 08/26/04

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Meet Doc