On mySimon: Sony Sound Bar
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet
TalkBack 28 of 188:
Next »
« Previous
Its not a myth - Think about it.
The actual software product that is Windows, is just as secure, and probably more secure than the than Linux simply because the entire source code isn't sitting in the lap of every script kiddie and virus writer. Open source has its advantages when it comes to recognizing and removing potential security threats, don't get me wrong, but it also allows anyone with the desire, to quickly devise new methods of attack. If you think Linux systems haven't been comprosed, wake up. The viri and vulnerabilities you hear about are only the tip of the iceberg. The real vulnerabilities, the pro "crackers" keep to themselves, so that they can exploit them to their advantage. What good is a security hole if the rest of the world knows about it and can correct it? The real vulnerabilities sure aren't exploited by stupid viri and worms that do nothing more than clog bandwidth and relay spam. Think about it.

No OS is perfect, but when a "knowledgeable" admin locks them down it doesn't matter whether its a Windows box, a linux box, or a Novell Server, its going to be secure.

The products are secure, but a machine is only as smart as the user operating it, and there-in lies the problem. The reason MS gets hit with all the viri that seem to completely miss the Linux and *nix systems isn't just because they have a bigger market share, its because of the computer literacy level of the masses using Windows.

The average Linux user is fairly knowledgable about the use of a computer, the same can not be said for the average Windows user. If you were to replace all of the Windows desktops in use today with Linux ones, the viri and other "security" issues would plague the Linux desktops, because instead of having a user base composed of 99% computer literate invididuals, you would end up with a user base composed of 80-90% idiots that will click any attachment that comes into their email box.

Point of the story is that 99% of all security issues arrive from user error or ignorance. I've been using Windows since I can't even remember, and I've never gotten a virus or had a server or workstation compromised on my office's network. If you patch regularly, lock down the network, lock down the servers, lock down email via policy and controls, and educate the users on your network, 95% of the security issues vanish, and the issues that still exist, are going to exist whether you are running Windows or Linux, so you have to learn to adapt and deal with it.
Posted by: tamuhockey   Posted on: 06/02/04 You are currently: a Guest | Members login | Terms of Use

Alert moderator to an offensive message

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

Linux IS more secure  ONEstar | 06/02/04
Although some corporations...  ShadeTree | 06/02/04
regardless  stephen732@... | 06/02/04
Anybody who trusts a desktop is delerious  oldskool | 06/02/04
Get your facts straight.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/02/04
Which facts?  bgoss@... | 06/02/04
Linux is more secure ONLY when ...  George Mitchell | 06/02/04
I Agree about the properly admin part.  JoeMama_z | 06/02/04
A great many of the world's largest corporations also use Windows  Stewart Cannon | 06/02/04
my dear watson...  ONEstar | 06/04/04
For now it is more secure  voska | 06/02/04
IS Linux more secure?  mwagner@... | 06/03/04
Get a clue....  tgrady | 06/03/04
depends on what you want to do...  ryusen | 06/03/04
exactly  ONEstar | 06/04/04
No need for a clue here....  ONEstar | 06/04/04
He did get one thing right  bidemytime | 06/02/04
Novell Netware?  James Schroer | 06/02/04
good question  Hanover Phist | 06/02/04
advice  toadlife | 06/02/04
Virus writers and graffiti artists?  Squawkbox | 06/02/04
CEO = Head Bean Counter  Chad_z | 06/02/04
Thing to differentiate...  mabricen | 06/02/04
Just found out  mabricen | 06/02/04
And fixed in the KB article  Confused by religion | 06/02/04
MS security problems are DESIGN INTENT - they built it that way!  oldskool | 06/02/04
It's a myth-take!  jellyclock | 06/02/04
Its not a myth - Think about it.  tamuhockey | 06/02/04
Speaking of myth  Chad_z | 06/02/04
That's not a myth either  tamuhockey | 06/02/04
True, but....  tgrady | 06/03/04
security by obscurity  avdp | 06/02/04
Listen to your own arguement.  tamuhockey | 06/02/04
and this is why...  ryusen | 06/02/04
re: security by obscurity  toadlife | 06/02/04
bang on jelly ... you can hide a barn behind a hanky if its far enough away  oldskool | 06/02/04
Faulty Logic  tamuhockey | 06/02/04
Faulty Logic?  FederalistPaperBoy | 06/02/04
Of course  tamuhockey | 06/02/04
and what happens when...  ryusen | 06/02/04
Lovebug  Linux User 147560 | 06/02/04
your firewall routes traffic to a bug ridden, flawed design called WINDOWS  oldskool | 06/02/04
I got your logic... RIGHT HERE!!  Ployd_Farker | 06/02/04
I could be misinformed....  tgrady | 06/03/04
More Crap...  Da-Man | 06/02/04
you obviously don't understand forced perspective  oldskool | 06/02/04
Please step away from the fantasy world  toadlife | 06/02/04
ahem...  ryusen | 06/02/04
I agree  toadlife | 06/02/04
my main point  ryusen | 06/02/04
WRONG, Again!!!  Da-Man | 06/02/04
Quit trolling your sales pitch  toadlife | 06/02/04
Learn to READ!  tgrady | 06/03/04
Hellllooo!  toadlife | 06/04/04
Do you UNDERSTAND it, or did you just READ it?  tamuhockey | 06/04/04
...a 2nd hand account?  lildog7 | 06/07/04
Platform is rock solid...  Mike Cox | 06/02/04
If Symantec is so expert...  Anton Philidor | 06/02/04
I disagree..  Patrick Jones | 06/02/04
Symantec is thinking a lot about Linux these days ...  George Mitchell | 06/02/04
Thanks for the interesting post!  FederalistPaperBoy | 06/02/04
Symantec market research  Yagotta B. Kidding | 06/02/04
Very interesting indeed!  FederalistPaperBoy | 06/02/04
CEO is supposed to focus on strategic vision not marketing  oldskool | 06/02/04
scary this CEO's depth of understanding of attack vectors  oldskool | 06/02/04
You misread the comment.  Anton Philidor | 06/02/04
its the MS experience that creates VIRII, not the hackers  oldskool | 06/02/04
Problem?  rapson | 06/02/04
Some admins have a dream...  Anton Philidor | 06/02/04
No, I'm saying MS made bad choices whcih can not be overridden  oldskool | 06/02/04
Windows *is* secure... Oh and buy our products!  prime21 | 06/02/04
not true, security admin is complex, LINUX could use easy tools too  oldskool | 06/02/04
Linux virus free? Since when?  tgrady | 06/03/04
Wow, seems the ABM crowd is in usual form.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/02/04
Huh?  bgoss@... | 06/02/04
The reason  rapson | 06/02/04
Do you mean like the Apache attacks?  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/02/04
There're always a few  rapson | 06/02/04
Cumon Carl, admit that Windows admin is less technical than *NIX  oldskool | 06/03/04
Nope  rapson | 06/03/04
OK, build a Windows servedr without NTFS and MS's TCP/IP stack for starters  oldskool | 06/03/04
Do you mean Apache on WIndows attacks?  B.O.F.H. | 06/02/04
Yes ax  Protector | 06/02/04
Apps vs. OS  libertyaikido | 06/02/04
Why?  j.m.galvin | 06/02/04
because they are irrational...  JoeMama_z | 06/02/04
re: because they are irrational...  bgoss@... | 06/02/04
lol  JoeMama_z | 06/02/04
That doesn't explain...  rapson | 06/02/04
Various reasons  rapson | 06/02/04
you are making assumptions...  ryusen | 06/02/04
Possibly  rapson | 06/02/04
differing motives.  ryusen | 06/02/04
I would press the button  Linux User 147560 | 06/02/04
btw2  PA-ITGuy | 06/02/04
re: btw2  bgoss@... | 06/02/04
agreed  PA-ITGuy | 06/02/04
agree also  bgoss@... | 06/02/04
yep  PA-ITGuy | 06/02/04
Hacked by someone actively poking  Linux User 147560 | 06/02/04
Ax never has the facts.  bjbrock | 06/02/04
HERE's YOUR FACTS!  Da-Man | 06/02/04
do you facts have details?  ryusen | 06/02/04
ghs tries to sell RTOS with posix interface to defence= competitor to linux  hipparchus2000 | 06/05/04
Facts are facts, myth propogation is marketing  ONEstar | 06/02/04
FACTS, YOU PEOPLE WANT FACTS!!! Read Message  Da-Man | 06/02/04
go read my reply to one of your posts...  ryusen | 06/03/04
Strangely, Symantec profits from the "myth"  Robert Crocker | 06/02/04
one fact you ignore  ryusen | 06/02/04
Message has been deleted.  jellyclock | 06/02/04
I had a loyal MSDN type show me how to bypass all MS security once ...  oldskool | 06/02/04
And now I know your full of it.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/02/04
so you never got the secret handshake, eh?  oldskool | 06/02/04
You're a L0ser...  Da-Man | 06/02/04
New ID!  Linux User 147560 | 06/02/04
too bad you needed to change the topic  oldskool | 06/02/04
ghs sell RTOS with posix intergface = competitor to linux  hipparchus2000 | 06/05/04
I find that message deletion very telling  jellyclock | 06/02/04
Just re-post it.  FederalistPaperBoy | 06/02/04
Get over yourself, no one cares anyways...  Da-Man | 06/02/04
wow look.. a new troll... (nt)  ryusen | 06/02/04
Same troll new name  Linux User 147560 | 06/02/04
No, he's different.  Linux_Developer | 06/03/04
it_cxristian and southern pride, etal...  ryusen | 06/03/04
An example of someone not connected with reality  Arrg | 06/02/04
I am constantly amazed by some folks here...  Confused by religion | 06/02/04
An excellent point.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/02/04
Great post the URL or IP Address  sa_z | 06/02/04
Yes you can  tamuhockey | 06/02/04
Of course.  sa_z | 06/02/04
back at you  tamuhockey | 06/02/04
back at you  sa_z | 06/02/04
To sa  tamuhockey | 06/02/04
Re: To sa  Linux_Developer | 06/03/04
Re: RE: to SA  tamuhockey | 06/03/04
an admin should know however...  JoeMama_z | 06/02/04
Superior admin skills  Yagotta B. Kidding | 06/02/04
Here you go.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/02/04
A question  Robert Crocker | 06/02/04
Thought so!  sa_z | 06/02/04
cant protect against DOS attacks....  JoeMama_z | 06/02/04
yes you can  tamuhockey | 06/02/04
somehow i doubt....  JoeMama_z | 06/02/04
You aren't an admin, obviously.  tgrady | 06/03/04
linux is a major platform in server os market  hipparchus2000 | 06/05/04
Request for more info...  FederalistPaperBoy | 06/02/04
Excellence stories  michael-t | 06/02/04
You're kind of amazing at times yourself, Milly  FederalistPaperBoy | 06/02/04
Pure wisdom from the initiated....  michael-t | 06/02/04
Sigh...  Confused by religion | 06/02/04
I would much rather  michael-t | 06/02/04
Made me laugh!  tgrady | 06/03/04
Made me sad  michael-t | 06/03/04
the fault in your argument...  ryusen | 06/02/04
Not really...  Confused by religion | 06/02/04
in one sense, yes, but...  ryusen | 06/03/04
From Symantec, the we rely on the misfortune of others  FilledOut | 06/02/04
Thompson IS A LIAR  RobertoSalazar | 06/02/04
Can you PROVE he's wrong? (NT)  PA-ITGuy | 06/02/04
He Only Works on Windows Systems  MoYoToSoTo | 06/02/04
Are you sure?  PA-ITGuy | 06/03/04
WRONG Again!!!  Da-Man | 06/02/04
"Facts"? How about "truth"?  Linux_Developer | 06/03/04
Support for Windows and EAL4 (don't hook it up to the Internet!)  B.O.F.H. | 06/02/04
Nuts and Bolts from Keys and Locks  ParadigmOdyssey | 06/02/04
BZZZT!! Nuts and Bolts was a McAfee Product  Confused by religion | 06/02/04
That is very original  michael-t | 06/02/04
THIS IS SO SIMPLE!!!!!  Protector | 06/02/04
And no, grandma doesn't have a firewall  Protector | 06/02/04
what about attachments dude  hipparchus2000 | 06/02/04
clicking on an attachment  hipparchus2000 | 06/02/04
...  Protector | 06/02/04
if you were using linux  hipparchus2000 | 06/02/04
Riddle Me This Then:  swbobcat | 06/02/04
Because their idi0ts?  Da-Man | 06/02/04
greenhills sells a competitor to linux called integrity RTOS  hipparchus2000 | 06/02/04
Without Microsoft, There would be no Symantec  claytonmuhler | 06/02/04
Without Microsoft there would be no YOU  Da-Man | 06/02/04
Misguided little boy!  Linux User 147560 | 06/02/04
Da boy  ONEstar | 06/03/04
Symantec  ctperimeter | 06/02/04
This is true.  robhare | 06/03/04
where do you get 94%?  hipparchus2000 | 06/05/04
any system that  V Sanders | 06/03/04
If The Tables Were Turned  ginseng37 | 06/03/04
Foolishness  scifirules@... | 06/03/04
A "mith" against unbiased, factual information?  solyom@... | 06/03/04
One question...Where does Symantic make the bulk of its MONEY?  Laff | 06/03/04

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement
advertisement
Click Here
  • Smart Tech Expert advice on innovations in healthcare and the green technologies that make it happen. Find out more
  • Smart Business Discussion and advice on management issues that revolve around making your world smarter and more useful. More Smart Advice
  • Smart People The best and worst moves in the management and strategy trenches. Learn More