On BNET: Poll: Are You Greedy or a Do-Gooder?
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet
TalkBack 20 of 34:
Next »
« Previous
No respect
Companies consider their software intellectual property, with monetary value.
But they fail to adequately acknowledge that the discovery of flaws is also intellectual property with value, monetary and otherwise.

If I find a bug, report it responsibly and nothing happens, I am being robbed of the opportunity to demonstrate my skill, which can lead to job opportunities and respect in the industry. To deny these researches this is pigheaded and wrong, as well as harmful to the public in general. These researches are providing a valuable service for free. Companies had better recognize this or figure out how to release software without bugs. (No, it can't be done, so they'd better work on their relationships with these researchers.)

Do I have any sympathy for the software companies? No. Because in the end, I the user am the one who is hurt by their stubborness.

That said, publishing a flaw publicly without allowing the company time to patch is irresponsible, but the article seems to indicate this is a declining practive among security researchers.
Posted by: shraven   Posted on: 08/17/06 You are currently: a Guest | Members login | Terms of Use

Alert moderator to an offensive message

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

Its the  not of this world | 08/17/06
I agree;  Suicida| | 08/17/06
Cheap way to find flaws  SteveTheWirePuller | 08/17/06
Valid concerns from true flaw finders  Boot_Agnostic | 08/17/06
Public dissemination of vulnerabilities  Anton Philidor | 08/17/06
A problem...  ju1ce | 08/17/06
Why would the idea fail?  Anton Philidor | 08/17/06
well it can...and it can't..  Monkey_MCSE | 08/17/06
another question...sorry  Monkey_MCSE | 08/17/06
The organization's purpose...  Anton Philidor | 08/17/06
And...  Anton Philidor | 08/17/06
and how many years did it take them??  Monkey_MCSE | 08/17/06
If no alternative operating systems...  Anton Philidor | 08/18/06
Fair's fair  Yagotta B. Kidding | 08/17/06
Flaw finders to software makers: It's payback time  puppadave | 08/17/06
IF THERE'S ANYTHING WRONG WITH A COMPUTER OR SOFTWARE IT'S A VIRUS !  BALTHOR | 08/17/06
Message has been deleted.  Colonel Panijk | 08/18/06
Flaw Finders  eryxias7@... | 08/17/06
What's the limit?  rpmyers1 | 08/18/06
No respect  shraven | 08/17/06
Last thing vendors want: explaining changes to outsiders  ejhonda | 08/17/06
Producing responses  dmhunter@... | 08/17/06
Bad headline  John L. Ries | 08/17/06
Shakedown  DaveSoNSo | 08/17/06
That's called "blackmail"  John L. Ries | 08/18/06
Ignorance is bliss, ay?  Tialin | 08/17/06
Well...  Anton Philidor | 08/17/06
Inconsistent expectations  DaveSoNSo | 08/17/06
When I pay for Software I Expect it to Work  OldTimer1 | 08/21/06
It's always Microsoft  AAWW | 08/17/06
I wouldn't say most flawed...  jasonp@... | 08/18/06
software flaws  jhinkson@... | 08/17/06
Not likely....  Leria | 08/18/06
Unlikely but possible  tony@... | 08/18/06

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement
advertisement